The defense is 1 piece away from being set.

rumman

Registered User
Sep 10, 2008
16,441
12,824
Rose colored glasses? FAR from it, I just don't see the point in being critical about games that are completely worthless.

At least save it for October 9th when the games count.
Who’s being critical? Can’t comment on the game? I thought that hockey forums exist for that very reason……..
 

mydnyte

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Sep 8, 2004
15,390
2,070
You're correct Leafs are lacking a true #1 Dman.

However that solution was to either draft one instead of drafting wingers, and when the Leafs signed Tavares it should have resulted in Marner or Nylander being traded for a #1/top pairing Dman.

Instead of signing Tavares the Leafs should have waited and used that $$ on local Ontario born Alex Pietrangelo a UFA, who has now lead 2 teams STL and Vegas to Stanley Cups since Leafs signed Taveras.

View attachment 908387 View attachment 908388

Alex Pietrangelo on the Cup winning ST. Louis Blues & Vegas Golden Knights
they could have had both ...and should have signed him.
 

myleafs

Registered User
May 25, 2021
2,423
2,657
you must be brand new here. NOBODY was more critical of them than me last season.

But that opinion was not based on the first pre season game of the year.

When It's time to be critical I assure you I'll be leading the charge.

September 23rd 2024 isn't the time.
When I see the same patterns as usual, it definitely triggers something in me, and last nights game was the same. If its another year of the same old same old, my interest will plummet even further so I was really hoping Id see something different. Ill give Berube a chance to put his stamp on the team but its not him Im worried about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ULF_55

ULF_55

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
87,124
18,830
Mountain Standard Ti
Visit site
you must be brand new here. NOBODY was more critical of them than me last season.

But that opinion was not based on the first pre season game of the year.

When It's time to be critical I assure you I'll be leading the charge.

September 23rd 2024 isn't the time.
My concern about last night was on the individual level not structure.

They were slow.
They looked opposite of mobile.
Structure will help cover up this deficiency but they aren't good enough or perhaps I should say talented enough to completely cover that degree of deficiency.

Perhaps the opposition were just superior skaters?
 
Last edited:

rumman

Registered User
Sep 10, 2008
16,441
12,824
When I see the same patterns as usual, it definitely triggers something in me, and last nights game was the same. If its another year of the same old same old, my interest will plummet even further so I was really hoping Id see something different. Ill give Berube a chance to put his stamp on the team but its not him Im worried about.
we’ve all seen this oh so many times, hard not to comment as such……..
 

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,372
15,994
My concern about last night was on the individual level not structure.

They were slow.
The looked opposite of mobile.
Structure will help cover up this deficiency but they aren't good enough or perhaps I should say talented enough to completely cover that degree of deficiency.

Perhaps the opposition were just superior skaters?

You think a team that was about 85% AHL players were Superior skaters?

Come on let's be serious.

One team was filled with hungry players looking to earn jobs.

The other was filled with mostly established players that all knew their spots were secure with the exception of maybe 3 players who all had 1 goal which was to get out healthy.

They did that as far as I know.

They didn't even try for half the game and STILL took it to OT.

No the AHL team are not superior skaters, if they We're they wouldn't be in the AHL, they'd be in the NHL.

What you saw last night was a team trying to earn jobs VS a team that knows they are on the team, knows the game is worthless because it is and just wanted to get out healthy.
 

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,372
15,994
When I see the same patterns as usual, it definitely triggers something in me, and last nights game was the same. If its another year of the same old same old, my interest will plummet even further so I was really hoping Id see something different. Ill give Berube a chance to put his stamp on the team but its not him Im worried about.

Did you think 5 years of a routine was going to vanish in 1 pre season game?

Give it time to gel.
 

NVious

Registered User
Dec 20, 2022
1,546
3,449
If we had Fox/Makar/Josi/Hughes we'd be amazing. This team is truly 1, maybe 2 (Drai/McDavid/Shesterkin) pieces away.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rumman

thusk

Registered User
Jul 15, 2011
4,434
2,287
Chicoutimi
Did you think 5 years of a routine was going to vanish in 1 pre season game?

Give it time to gel.

look like some people thinking that way..

People don't understand by exemple the system will start to be really acquire like at chritsmas time...

Exemple with Florida, we started to see the new identity like in jabuary/february under Maurice...

But fans here after 1 pre-seqson game already on red flag...It's just hillarious
 

BobClarkesfrontteeth

Registered User
Feb 6, 2020
1,485
958
Parts unknown
I'm still upset at losing out on Roy. OEL, Hakenpa and Timmins combine for his cap hit.

Rielly - Tanev

McCabe - Roy

Benoit - Lily
I'm not. His contract will look alot like the Ryan Graves contract very quickly. People talk about Liljegren and his lack fo physical play in front of the net and his give aways. Roy is the same player.
 

rumman

Registered User
Sep 10, 2008
16,441
12,824
If we had Fox/Makar/Josi/Hughes we'd be amazing. This team is truly 1, maybe 2 (Drai/McDavid/Shesterkin) pieces away.
They can’t afford any of the players mentioned because , well you know………
 

Dale Gribble

Registered User
Feb 9, 2019
447
410
I think we're more than 1 piece away. Not sold on Ekman-Larsson, Hakanpää and especially Liljegren. Actually still confused as to why Treliving signed Liljegren to $3 mill, he struggles to stay in the line up when healthy.

Just seems like yet another year of patch work defence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rumman

myleafs

Registered User
May 25, 2021
2,423
2,657
Did you think 5 years of a routine was going to vanish in 1 pre season game?

Give it time to gel.
Not vanish but yea I kind of expected our top guys including our new captain to make a statement, but it was just the same as usual. Doesn't mean it won't change and maybe our top guys figure out what kind of sacrifice it takes to go deep and maybe Berube brings that out in them but after one preseason game it looks the same to me. Time will tell.
 

myleafs

Registered User
May 25, 2021
2,423
2,657
look like some people thinking that way..

People don't understand by exemple the system will start to be really acquire like at chritsmas time...

Exemple with Florida, we started to see the new identity like in jabuary/february under Maurice...

But fans here after 1 pre-seqson game already on red flag...It's just hillarious
Right, because everyones concerns are based on one preseason game...what is hilarious is the excuses already being made....after one preseason game. Best one for me so far is the leafs played a bunch of AHL'ers last game who were really trying hard so thats why we lost and looked average. Keep em coming. Comedy gold Jerry comedy gold.
 

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,372
15,994
Not vanish but yea I kind of expected our top guys including our new captain to make a statement, but it was just the same as usual. Doesn't mean it won't change and maybe our top guys figure out what kind of sacrifice it takes to go deep and maybe Berube brings that out in them but after one preseason game it looks the same to me. Time will tell.

Of course it does, you don't play one system for 5 years and then just automatically drop that system and adopt a completely new system in 1 game.

It's going to take time
 

thusk

Registered User
Jul 15, 2011
4,434
2,287
Chicoutimi
Right, because everyones concerns are based on one preseason game...what is hilarious is the excuses already being made....after one preseason game. Best one for me so far is the leafs played a bunch of AHL'ers last game who were really trying hard so thats why we lost and looked average. Keep em coming. Comedy gold Jerry comedy gold.

For sure guy playing like a practice to be ready for regular season vs player whos playing like they are in playoff because they are fighting for their job... You don't have the same emergency

for sure that should be a concern...
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad