St. Brown is a fun young player, very good in the slot. But he’s not in Diggs tier. Reynolds probably wouldn’t have made the bills roster (or if he did would be in a Sheefield/Shakir type Seth role). That’s what I’m getting at, there’s just way more targets to go around in that offense.
I think you're being a little harsh on Detroit. One of my best friends is a big Lions fan, I've watched quite a few of their games over recent years. I've been at the front of their hype train, even before they were on hard knocks. I saw the same green shoots there as we all saw when McBeane first took charge of the Bills.
Of course, the key to their success is that OL which is hands down best in league. And while I'd agree their skill players are on the whole inferior to the Bills, i don't think they are as bad as you make out.
If St Brown isn't an elite receiver, then he's certainly at the top of the tier below. He also seems to have an unbelievably good personality / work ethic, a la Gabe Davis - which does seem to be a rare trait at the position.
Josh Reynolds is stupidly under rated, always has been even since his days in LA, IMO. He also has very good chemistry with Goff. That was a Beane-esque pickup for them if i ever saw one. He's a legit WR3 on most teams in the league.
They also have a few other options - Khalif Raymond is a useful gadget player, Jahmyr Gibbs out of the backfield (they have lined him up at receiver too IIRC) & Jameson Williams returning soon as their deep guy. Trading away TJ Hockenson has been one of the very few things they have done recently which i disagreed with - but i think they might have fixed it already with LaPorta. He looks legit.
I'm very happy with the Kincaid pick BTW. More so for the many benefits we discussed over the summer provided by switching to 2TE/12 personnel, than the particular player himself. The fruits are already showing & we're only three games into the season. And while Kincaid's numbers haven't been crazy - they have still been pretty good.
I guess the point I'm making is that LaPorta could easily become the best TE of the strongest ever class, but i won't lose any sleep over it because we also got one of the good ones & it's potentially transformed what was an explosive but one dimensional offence, into something which could become Championship calibre.