BaseballCoach
Registered User
- Dec 15, 2006
- 21,328
- 9,673
It started when someone compared their goal scoring in the NCAA.Why would you talk about Caufield in a Farrell thread in the first place?
It started when someone compared their goal scoring in the NCAA.Why would you talk about Caufield in a Farrell thread in the first place?
Yes, Farrell can be a strong contributor on the PK, for example.Farrell is more well-rounded - he is a better playmaker and also better defensively than Caufield.
Yes, Farrell can be a strong contributor on the PK, for example.
Still, with the following prospects, Montreal has a lot of smaller players either already in Montreal or coming up through the system and, other than for Ds, I am not considering 5'11" as small, like in Suzuki's case, but his being sturdy at 208 lbs helps, in his case:
Caufield: 5'7", 174 lbs
Harris: 5'11", 189 lbs
Gallagher: 5'9", 186 lbs
Mesar: 5'10", 174 lbs
Farrell: 5'9", 175 lbs
Hutson: 5'9", 148 lbs
I didn’t compare their goal scoring or compare them at all, you should follow the conversation better.It started when someone compared their goal scoring in the NCAA.
It is an issue with Harris. He doesn't win one on one battles in his own zone. He needs more strength to progress to eat he could/should be as a D in the NHL, a top-4 D.Caufield has shown it isn't an issue.
Harris has shown it isn't an issue.
Gallagher is an anchor, not part of the core. Who cares.
Mesar hasn't announced he's a NHL player yet.
So it's not really a concern.
Caufields a superstar so hardly a problemYes, Farrell can be a strong contributor on the PK, for example.
Still, with the following prospects, Montreal has a lot of smaller players either already in Montreal or coming up through the system and, other than for Ds, I am not considering 5'11" as small, like in Suzuki's case, but his being sturdy at 208 lbs helps, in his case:
Caufield: 5'7", 174 lbs
Harris: 5'11", 189 lbs
Gallagher: 5'9", 186 lbs
Mesar: 5'10", 174 lbs
Farrell: 5'9", 175 lbs
Hutson: 5'9", 148 lbs
i doubt Habs throw in the towel on Mesar so quickly. He was a first round pick in June.Caufields a superstar so hardly a problem
Gallagher can barely play 60 NHL games anymore, he's already a 3rd liner, his injuries will take care of the contract itself
Harris unfortunately is now a place holder til Hutson gets here, he's just not in the long term plans with the emergence of both Guhle AND Xhekaj
For Mesar and Farrell, it really feels like we only need one of the 2 to really make it, and Farrell definitely has the inside track on that one
Farrell can "settle" as a 3rd liner if he can'tmake the top6, but if Mesar doesn't become a bona-fide top6er then there is no use for him really
It's harsh sure, but not everybody is making this party honestly
Is there any support for that claim?Harris unfortunately is now a place holder til Hutson gets here, he's just not in the long term plans with the emergence of both Guhle AND Xhekaj
Lol, you'd like that wouldn't youIs there any support for that claim?
He’s literally the best rookie with Guhle hahaPeople continuously underrate Harris.
He can play both sides on defense. Man's already a 4/5.
He's fine really, but I just don't see a long term future here if we're being super honestPeople continuously underrate Harris.
He can play both sides on defense. Man's already a 4/5.
He's fine really, but I just don't see a long term future here if we're being super honest
Like if he's never ever going to get powerplay time here, and it doesnt look like he EVER will sadly with Matheson(ugh), Guhle, Barron and even Xhekaj getting time amazingly, then he'll never be able to be the best version of himself we would need him to be
I just don't see how management looks at the D situation with a couple vets, with all the kids here already and the kids coming in, and with the PP QB spot in constant Flux and a potential pp phenom on the way I just don't see how Harris is in the long term plans is all
I personally think he's a trade asset, and a really good one at that
He may be our next kulak in terms of usage and versatility. With a little more skill.People continuously underrate Harris.
He can play both sides on defense. Man's already a 4/5.
He's fine really, but I just don't see a long term future here if we're being super honest
Like if he's never ever going to get powerplay time here, and it doesnt look like he EVER will sadly with Matheson(ugh), Guhle, Barron and even Xhekaj getting time amazingly, then he'll never be able to be the best version of himself we would need him to be
I just don't see how management looks at the D situation with a couple vets, with all the kids here already and the kids coming in, and with the PP QB spot in constant Flux and a potential pp phenom on the way I just don't see how Harris is in the long term plans is all
I personally think he's a trade asset, and a really good one at that
34 points in 21 games.Sean Farrell with 4 assists tonight, makes 30 points in 20 games.
Fantilli been on fire since returning from WJCFarrell is only behind Fantili in the NCAA in pts/game
His teammate Luke Hughes scored 4 goals tonight. Fantilli had 2 assists.Fantilli been on fire since returning from WJC
Farrell is only behind Fantili in the NCAA in pts/game
His ability to score goals will most likely be the factor on where he'll end up in the lineup since his creative playmaking is top-six level. He did well in the olympics and is scoring goals at a good pace at the college level which is encouraging to see. There is not a lot of under-sized scoring wingers in the nhl, but I have no problem thinking he'll be at least be a middle-six forward on a strong team with the upside of a legitimate top-six forward and special units contributor. First or second powerplay and possibly the PK due to his skating abilities.
Three nhlers comes to mind in the undersized scoring wingers category that I like to compare Farrell to:
Mats Zuccarello
Jesper Bratt
Mikael Granlund
Maybe I overrate him a bit but he is definitely a top-5 prospect on the habs. At this point, I just can't see him bust. Hopefully the habs will sign him to his entry-level contract and he ends up playing games for the canadiens at the tail end of the season.
That's not a true overall picture of the team. Although you brought up two defencemen, I'll leave them off my list:Yes, Farrell can be a strong contributor on the PK, for example.
Still, with the following prospects, Montreal has a lot of smaller players either already in Montreal or coming up through the system and, other than for Ds, I am not considering 5'11" as small, like in Suzuki's case, but his being sturdy at 208 lbs helps, in his case:
Caufield: 5'7", 174 lbs
Harris: 5'11", 189 lbs
Gallagher: 5'9", 186 lbs
Mesar: 5'10", 174 lbs
Farrell: 5'9", 175 lbs
Hutson: 5'9", 148 lbs