Value of: Scott Mayfield

[Nothingbutglass]

Love completely one-sided takes like this. I don't know much about Mayfield but you clearly don't know much about Dermott. At least reach across the aisle, man.

Dermott blows. He's a fringe NHL player at this point. No value to playoff teams.

 

[Hockey 4 Life]

Dermott blows. He's a fringe NHL player at this point. No value to playoff teams.

This is incorrect, but you are entitled to your opinion.

 

[sens13]

Love completely one-sided takes like this. I don't know much about Mayfield but you clearly don't know much about Dermott. At least reach across the aisle, man.

This is incorrect, but you are entitled to your opinion.

How is dermott not a fringe d-man? He's been in the league for 5 years and is still a bottom paring d-man. mayfield is a top 4 rhd.

You say you don't know anything about mayfield but then say that dermott+ 2nd is fair? Those 2 things contradict each other.

I'd love to hear why you both think dermott has so much value

 

[Michael HOMERUNing]

lol because chychrun is going to cost a lot more than just a late 1st and a decent prospect

Then add more. It would be better than using these kind of assets on Mayfield

 

[miscs75]

Why not Holl instead of Dermott? Both are essentially bottom pairing guys but one is slightly undersized.

 

[EK392000]

How is dermott not a fringe d-man? He's been in the league for 5 years and is still a bottom paring d-man. mayfield is a top 4 rhd.

You say you don't know anything about mayfield but then say that dermott+ 2nd is fair? Those 2 things contradict each other.

I'd love to hear why you both think dermott has so much value

I never claimed Dermott had immense value and I never claimed he was better than Mayfield, hence why Toronto would be adding.

I also said that I don't know much about Mayfield, not that I don't know anything about him.

 

[WTFMAN99]

If that is the price why not change the 2nd to 1st and make a run an Chychrun?

Mayfield is good but is a little too similar to Muzzin. If we were going to make a trade for an RD I'd rather it be Josh Manson. Would be a hell of a lot cheaper than this proposed price

Leafs are actually stacked at LD - re-signed Rielly, Sandin long term guy...Muzzin another 2 years and even Dermott a competent bottom 4 LD is there.

Chychrun doesn't really play his off side and neither do the other guys listed with the exception of Dermott. Mayfield's cap hit is also attractive for the Leafs along with another year on his contract whereas Manson is expiring and again, Chychrun not a great fit.

 

[Buresflyingelbow]

Funny how Leaf fans say Dermott has so much value but he’s in every proposal lol. Guy is not worth more than a 5th round pick.

 

[Nothingbutglass]

This is incorrect, but you are entitled to your opinion.

No, its completely accurate, but you are entitled to yours.

 

[Fogelhund]

Funny how Leaf fans say Dermott has so much value but he’s in every proposal lol. Guy is not worth more than a 5th round pick.

Oh, so that's how you judge what value is? Seems fitting, as clearly you don't know the player.

He's posted here, because someone said a LD is a need for NYI. No, he's not a top LD, but to say a 5th round pick, is clearly ignorant of his play.

 

[sens13]

I never claimed Dermott had immense value and I never claimed he was better than Mayfield, hence why Toronto would be adding.

I also said that I don't know much about Mayfield, not that I don't know anything about him.

david savard got a 1st at the deadline last year. mayfeild has a 1 and a half year left. you really think a 2nd plus dermott is fair?
How much are you valuing dermott at because I'm sure most teams would not give more than a 3rd for him

 

[EK392000]

david savard got a 1st at the deadline last year. mayfeild has a 1 and a half year left. you really think a 2nd plus dermott is fair?
How much are you valuing dermott at because I'm sure most teams would not give more than a 3rd for him

I said it was reasonable, not fair. I said reasonable because the Leafs have a player that the Isles could use and the Isles have a player the Leafs could use. That is generally a reasonable basis for a trade. I also left it off with "good trading partners?". It should be clear that I wasn't trying to make a proposal, just pointing out that the Leafs and Isles could be good trading partners.

 

[Stuzchuk]

This guy reminds me so much of Zub.... he's be a perfect fit in OTT. I'd be willing to go Brannstrom, Greig, and a 2nd for him

 

[PAZ]

This guy reminds me so much of Zub.... he's be a perfect fit in OTT. I'd be willing to go Brannstrom, Greig, and a 2nd for him

If the Islanders plan to move Mayfield I imagine this would be a pretty competitive offer, assuming it's Ottawa's 2nd.

Mayfield should be worth at least 2 1sts at his cap hit + extra year, similar to Coleman.

 

[Stuzchuk]

If the Islanders plan to move Mayfield I imagine this would be a pretty competitive offer, assuming it's Ottawa's 2nd.

Mayfield should be worth at least 2 1sts at his cap hit + extra year, similar to Coleman.

OTT cant afford to lose a top #3 pick again, sadly

 

[SI90]

This guy reminds me so much of Zub.... he's be a perfect fit in OTT. I'd be willing to go Brannstrom, Greig, and a 2nd for him

If the Islanders plan to move Mayfield I imagine this would be a pretty competitive offer, assuming it's Ottawa's 2nd.

Mayfield should be worth at least 2 1sts at his cap hit + extra year, similar to Coleman.

I think mayfield has a lot of value but I don’t think he would fetch multiple 1sts. He’s not a point producer. Just a big mean steady defenseman. His cap hit is a huge asset but it’s only 1 more year.

I think if the isles were set on moving Mayfield(Im not convinced they are) that Brannstrom + Grieg + 2nd would be enough to get it done.

Brannstrom isn’t has highly touted as he once was but still has some value and potential because of his age.

Greig is legit. I’d prefer to get a center prospect back but it’s hard to turn down Greig.

if I’m trading Mayfield this is an offer I’d accept as an isles fan. Think it’s very fair.

ironically both Brannstrom and Greig were drafted with NYI picks.

 

[Fogelhund]

david savard got a 1st at the deadline last year. mayfeild has a 1 and a half year left. you really think a 2nd plus dermott is fair?
How much are you valuing dermott at because I'm sure most teams would not give more than a 3rd for him

Dermott would get a 2nd if traded... so value is two seconds.

 

[Filthy Dangles]

If the Islanders plan to move Mayfield I imagine this would be a pretty competitive offer, assuming it's Ottawa's 2nd.

Mayfield should be worth at least 2 1sts at his cap hit + extra year, similar to Coleman.

Woah...no.

 

[Filthy Dangles]

Scott Mayfield is way closer to Travis Dermott and a 2nd round pick than multiple first round picks in value.

Guys solid but nothing special.

 

[MattyW]

He's easily bringing back a 1st at minimum at the deadline. Playoff style defenseman, signed through next season for peanuts and a righty. He's likely the most valuable asset that NYI might want to trade.

 

[Buresflyingelbow]

Oh, so that's how you judge what value is? Seems fitting, as clearly you don't know the player.

He's posted here, because someone said a LD is a need for NYI. No, he's not a top LD, but to say a 5th round pick, is clearly ignorant of his play.

The borderline waiver wire Dermott? Yeah, I know who he is. Not an everyday NHL’er

 

[Fogelhund]

The borderline waiver wire Dermott? Yeah, I know who he is. Not an everyday NHL’er

Stop while you are way behind.

 

[Michael HOMERUNing]

When was the last time a 29 year old with a career high 19 points returned one 1st round pick, let alone multiple?

 

[PWJunior]

He's easily bringing back a 1st at minimum at the deadline. Playoff style defenseman, signed through next season for peanuts and a righty. He's likely the most valuable asset that NYI might want to trade.

Why is Dermott mentioned as a return? The Isles have zero use for him and have Robin Salo/Samuel Bolduc in the pipeline. At least offer the Isles an actual usable asset or two in these proposals.

 

[sens13]

When was the last time a 29 year old with a career high 19 points returned one 1st round pick, let alone multiple?

savard got a 1st last year at the deadline as a 30 year old when he had 6 points in 40 at that time and 11 in 68 the year before.

Some times teams are looking for defensive d-man not just offence ones