Proposal: Scheifele for Toews?

[JetsHomer]

LOL, what? So Scheifele was as good defensively as Toews was? Because he scored a whole whopping 3pts more than Toews, so I wouldn't consider his offense to be better. Even is more like it.

Scheifele wasn't as good as Toews was last year, in Toews worst season as a pro. What a crock.

Scheifele's defensive numbers were equal to Toews last year, and he scored 3 more points in 9 less games. Not that hard to say Scheifele had the better year

 

[sully1410]

And everyone of those players but Mackinnon bring a better defensive and special teams game.

Ummm....nope. Not at all.

 

[sully1410]

Scheifele's defensive numbers were equal to Toews last year, and he scored 3 more points in 9 less games. Not that hard to say Scheifele had the better year

Interestingly enough...he actually has better possession numbers in his rookie season than Toews did at the same point in his career. Funny hey? Tows scored better though...worth noting.

 

[imapylon]

It's clearly a trade both teams politely decline.

Just what I was thinking

 

[Hawkaholic]

Scheifele's defensive numbers were equal to Toews last year, and he scored 3 more points in 9 less games. Not that hard to say Scheifele had the better year

LOL, his defensive numbers.

He isn't as good as Toews defensively, I don't care what the numbers say/said. Toews is the better player, period, end of story.

 

[GoJetsGo55]

LOL, his defensive numbers.

He isn't as good as Toews defensively, I don't care what the numbers say/said. Toews is the better player, period, end of story.

Ah **** this guy just ended it.

We're done here folks.

Why didn't we think of that?

 

[JetsHomer]

LOL, his defensive numbers.

He isn't as good as Toews defensively, I don't care what the numbers say/said. Toews is the better player, period, end of story.

Well if hfboards forum user Hawkaholic says it then it it must be true. Close down this board, no need to discuss things just get Hawkaholic to tell us how things are

 

[sully1410]

Holy ****...we are still talking about this? For real?

No...we don't want Toews in exchange for Scheifele. Scheifele is just entering his prime and will be there from a long while...where as Toews will be leaving his over the next few years. He may already have done so given the sharp decline in his point production this season.

So we don't care if you think Toews is better or whatever. We don't want him in exchange for Scheifele. Not a chance.

 

[Group Chat Legend*]

I take Toews AINEC

Sad this is up for debate

 

[boanst]

I like Toews. Just not at 10.5 mill

 

[JetsHomer]

I take Toews AINEC

Sad this is up for debate

If you claim 'it's not even close' you are merely showing your ignorance at the season Scheifele had

 

[Group Chat Legend*]

If you claim 'it's not even close' you are merely showing your ignorance at the season Scheifele had

Oh wow the 'season' he had

Give me the guy with 3 rings and multiple great 'seasons'

 

[GoJetsGo55]

Oh wow the 'season' he had

Give me the guy with 3 rings and multiple great 'seasons'

How much of his past do we get to claim when we trade for him?

 

[Group Chat Legend*]

How much of his past do we get to claim when we trade for him?

How much of his future can you determine with that magic ball?

Oh wow, it's almost as if Toews has proven more than Scheifele...

 

[JetsHomer]

How much of his future can you determine with that magic ball?

Oh wow, it's almost as if Toews has proven more than Scheifele...

No one is arguing that dude. Scheifele was better than Toews last season. Toews is still the better and more valuable player overall. (Except probably not 4.4m better)

 

[Group Chat Legend*]

No one is arguing that dude. Scheifele was better than Toews last season. Toews is still the better and more valuable player overall. (Except probably not 4.4m better)

No one likes that contract, and I'm sure Toews knows he isn't worth 10.5

But my point stands - if I'm making a team I'm taking Toews more often than not. There are only a few centers I take over him, them being Crosby and Kopitar. And perhaps McDavid if I'm feeling ballsy

 

[KevinRedkey]

Gimme Sheifele. He's not quite as good as Toews (although not that far off), but he's younger and a hell of a lot cheaper.

How much of his future can you determine with that magic ball?

Oh wow, it's almost as if Toews has proven more than Scheifele...

Jagr has proven quite a lot. With your logic, you would trade your team's most valuable asset for him, right?

No one likes that contract, and I'm sure Toews knows he isn't worth 10.5

But my point stands - if I'm making a team I'm taking Toews more often than not. There are only a few centers I take over him, them being Crosby and Kopitar. And perhaps McDavid if I'm feeling ballsy

LMAO that's being ballsy?

99.9999999% of the Hockey community would take McDavid over Toews.
Ballsy would be the other way around.

 

[Teeder9]

Not even a Jets fan but i'd be pretty pissed at the management if they did that. Toews is better but for how long and at 10.5m. Not worth the chance

 

[bennysflyers16]

But he's not though? Scheifele faced tough comp and was used against other teams top lines through most of the season. The numbers say Couts faced slightly harder minutes (in terms of zone starts) but did significantly worse during those minutes offensively

One was in a playoff dog fight for half a year opposed to meaningless games. One also does not get top PP mins and one also has a legit #1 center playing in front of him, roles do play a part.

That being said, Zero chance the Jets make this trade , Toews is better than Schief right now, but contract, age, and where the Jets currently are as contenders, no chance Jets make the deal. Hawks would at least consider the deal imo.

 

[JetsHomer]

One was in a playoff dog fight for half a year opposed to meaningless games. One also does not get top PP mins and one also has a legit #1 center playing in front of him, roles do play a part.

That being said, Zero chance the Jets make this trade , Toews is better than Schief right now, but contract, age, and where the Jets currently are as contenders, no chance Jets make the deal. Hawks would at least consider the deal imo.

One also got outscored by 18 goals and 21 points in only 8 more games

 

[Group Chat Legend*]

Gimme Sheifele. He's not quite as good as Toews (although not that far off), but he's younger and a hell of a lot cheaper.



Jagr has proven quite a lot. With your logic, you would trade your team's most valuable asset for him, right?



LMAO that's being ballsy?

99.9999999% of the Hockey community would take McDavid over Toews.
Ballsy would be the other way around.

Having to use extreme parallels to be relevant in the discussion?

And yes, I take Toews every time before McDavid. He can show me another great season and then I might change my mind. Sorry I dont overvalue potential as much as Hf does

 

[JetsHomer]

Having to use extreme parallels to be relevant in the discussion?

And yes, I take Toews every time before McDavid. He can show me another great season and then I might change my mind. Sorry I dont overvalue potential as much as Hf does

Lol potential? McDavid just had a season where he has 10 less points than Toews in 35 less games. McDavid is the most valuable player in the league, and is much better than Toews today

If McDavid played the full year he probably would have outscored Toews by like 30 points...

 

[Hawkaholic]

Ah **** this guy just ended it.

We're done here folks.

Why didn't we think of that?

Well if hfboards forum user Hawkaholic says it then it it must be true. Close down this board, no need to discuss things just get Hawkaholic to tell us how things are

You can toss jokes all you want. Toews worst season (coming off of a Cup, and 3 WCF appearances in a row) was basically equal to Scheifs best season.

Has Scheif ever been nominated, let alone won the Selke?
Has Scheif ever scored 30 goals?
Has Scheif ever scored more than 61pts?

Yes, one good season for Scheif and suddendly he is better than Toews. LOL
If he can put up another 60pt season next year, I would be surprised. Whereas if Toews puts up another 50-60pt season next year, I would be surprised.

The only thing that makes this thread not completely laughable is Toews' salary. But he earned that salary by winning the Cup 3 times and the Conn Smythe, along with all of his other accolades.

What does Scheifele have?

 

[JetsHomer]

You can toss jokes all you want. Toews worst season (coming off of a Cup, and 3 WCF appearances in a row) was basically equal to Scheifs best season.

Has Scheif ever been nominated, let alone won the Selke?
Has Scheif ever scored 30 goals?
Has Scheif ever scored more than 61pts?

Yes, one good season for Scheif and suddendly he is better than Toews. LOL
If he can put up another 60pt season next year, I would be surprised. Whereas if Toews puts up another 50-60pt season next year, I would be surprised.

The only thing that makes this thread not completely laughable is Toews' salary. But he earned that salary by winning the Cup 3 times and the Conn Smythe, along with all of his other accolades.

What does Scheifele have?

The cold hard fact that he was a better hockey player in the 2015/2016 season than Toews

 

[oilerbear]

give me a break

Toews faced 5th hardest centre comp in the game.
81gm +16
18 evg 42evp
6ppg 9ppp
4shg 7shp

Schiefle 25th hardest centre comp in the game
71gm +16
22evg 50evp
7ppg 11ppp

Schiefle is one of the best young pvp centers to face top 40 comp.
There with the elite evp top 30 comp centers.
Mcdavid
Barkov
RNH
Draisatl
Monohan
Mackinnon
Trochek
Couturier