Americanadian
Registered User
I'm not sure Mete or Benn are NHL defenseman on a contender.I count 10 NHL Dmen without Gustafsson.
Rielly
Brodie
McCabe
Holl
Giordano
Liljegren
Timmins
Schenn
Benn
Mete
I'm not sure Mete or Benn are NHL defenseman on a contender.I count 10 NHL Dmen without Gustafsson.
Rielly
Brodie
McCabe
Holl
Giordano
Liljegren
Timmins
Schenn
Benn
Mete
I'm not sure Mete or Benn are NHL defenseman on a contender.
Isn't that an oxymoron because NHL teams don't carry 9-10D?As a #9 and 10D they are
They are not playing. You don't think they are 9 and 10 on a contender?I'm not sure Mete or Benn are NHL defenseman on a contender.
If you are 9th/10th on the depth chart you are not an NHL player.They are not playing. You don't think they are 9 and 10 on a contender?
I am not sure why we are talking about Tampa here but I like Cole/Perbix a lot. I view Cole=Giordano right now, Perbix=Liljegren and Bogosian=Schenn. Fleury is just bad. I am watching the TBL/FLA game right now and JBB just said he's most likely done making moves so that bodes well if you think their D is bad.Now look at Tampa's 4 thru 7 D.....is this a 4 thru 7 on a contender?
Ian Cole
Nick Perbix
Zach Bogosian
Haydn Fleury
LOL.....I......can'tIf you are 9th/10th on the depth chart you are not an NHL player.
I am not sure why we are talking about Tampa here but I like Cole/Perbix a lot. I view Cole=Giordano right now, Perbix=Liljegren and Bogosian=Schenn. Fleury is just bad. I am watching the TBL/FLA game right now and JBB just said he's most likely done making moves so that bodes well if you think their D is bad.
Would love Wilson on this team, but with the microscope we have on our team he’d get suspended faster than kadri ever did lolHave to admit when I saw Sandin to Washington I thought Wilson was coming back.
Not sure if it's been mentioned here but Gustaffson hasn't really been a PP merchant this season. He has more ES points than any Leaf defenseman (27). He has 0.94 primary points/60 at ES compared to 0.73 for Rielly.
Isn't that an oxymoron because NHL teams don't carry 9-10D?
Precise analysis. And sitting him this playoff would have led to off season unhappiness. Dealing with his unhappiness now for a very good return is very intelligentValue makes sense, sad to see a young promising player go, but he was unlikely to get the minutes here to improve his value so selling now made sense.
I'm just trying to point out that his production isn't strictly PP and he has been effective at ES too. Having 6% more Ozone starts than Rielly doesn't make 30% higher production a moot point.He also starts far more in the offensive zone than any of the Leafs defense do.
His Ozone start 5v5 % is 15.5 vs Riellys 9.1
I'm just trying to point out that his production isn't strictly PP and he has been effective at ES too. Having 6% more Ozone starts than Rielly doesn't make 30% higher production a moot point.
Where are you finding this data? I'd love to dive in.He also starts noticeably less in the Dzone 5v5 also.
Crazy high 5v5 Ozone starts, with almost league bottom Dzone starts 5v5 (out of 1000 minute defense, ranks #1 least) will certainly play a large role in being able to put up good offensive numbers.
For someone who never starts in the Dzone, his defensive zone turnovers are quite alot.
Dive in for Tampa if you think Nick Perbix is as good as Liljegren, and you think that Ian Cole, Perbix, Fleury, and Bogosian is the defense of a cup contender.Where are you finding this data? I'd love to dive in.
Where are you finding this data? I'd love to dive in.
considering both keep clearing waivers it doesn't look like there NHL D on bottom feeders eitherI'm not sure Mete or Benn are NHL defenseman on a contender.
Your sleeping heavily on perbix he's very similar to lilijgrenLOL.....I......can't
LOLOL
Clearing cap space, getting a similar/better D along with a 1st.Not sure what the point of this one was
I'm not sleeping on anything.Your sleeping heavily on perbix he's very similar to lilijgren
Both good young defenseman who are starting to play bigger roles. Both will be top 4D for a whole now
Oilers suddenly need a PPQB.I could be wrong, but I don’t think Gustafson is here to stay
I like him less now. I still think he's better than Sandin right now.Moneypuck .
I posted this in another thread but here's how he ranks 5v5 out of defensemen who've played at least 1000 minutes
#1 least amount of Dzone starts % of 56 qualified D
View attachment 659592
#1 Most amount of Ozone shift start %
View attachment 659594