This idea that Minnesota has a right to his UFA years and is going to arrange the contracts thusly -- just so that they can re-sign him later on -- man, I'd be livid in his shoes. The presumption of it is galling.
He's not going to spend one more solitary second in Minnesota than he has to, now. This maneuvering to position the Wild to be in a competitive negotiating stance for his NEXT contract is going to be immaterial. Sure, maybe their odds in free agency were never great, but there was always at least the chance he warmed to the place. Now that they have put him over a barrel, he's going to sign somewhere else on his next contract, anywhere else, for non-financial reasons.
They're well on their way to poisoning the well with him if they force him to give up UFA years on THIS contract. It isn't going to matter if they are in a position to compete for his services next time around, in terms of cap space, if the experience today leaves him with the taste of ashes in his mouth.
Why they have so sabotaged their goodwill with their rising star is a mystery to me. They could have worked with him, worked on a fair compromise on a two- or three-year deal, leaving the door open to re-signing him later on. Now? He's not going to have any interest in staying long term now, feeling ill treated after they used every ounce of their leverage under his 10.2(c) status this summer.
If they eventually force him to sign one of the contracts under discussion (RFA + 1 or 2 UFA years), which seems probable since he has no recourse under the CBA, then this is the last contract he's going to sign with Minnesota.
There won't be enough money under the sun to convince him to stay as a free agent, if they piss him off royally now. Fighting him today to get into a position to offer him a competitive contract tomorrow won't matter, if he already considers the relationship beyond repair.
I question the strategy from Guerin. I question the wisdom of going to war with what is arguably your franchise player, evidently with the objective to convince Kaprizov to sign up in ~2024 for the rest of his prime years. Going to war isn't going to ingratiate yourself with him. It's going to alienate him.
It didn't need to go down this way. I think Guerin is cutting off his nose to spite his face.