Speculation: Rumour, Trade, and Free Agent Speculation 2018-19 - Part VIII
- Thread starter Maukkis
- Start date
- Status
No chance
remember when a 27 year old 70 pt 2-way winger(+ other stuff) was traded for a 21 year old Tyler Seguin and how that ended up in the long run?
puck stoppa
Registered User
Oh man these proposals.
Here is my guess.
1st, Comrie, Spacek for Duchene.
Petan for a pick.
Sign Stone in summer.
Recoup picks and prospects for Trouba at draft.
Here is my guess.
1st, Comrie, Spacek for Duchene.
Petan for a pick.
Sign Stone in summer.
Recoup picks and prospects for Trouba at draft.
_______________________________________________________
It's really just my opinion, but he looks "very talented" and has some great moves. He's sort of a fancy player, that can make those miraculous plays. His point per game average is around (1.1) I believe, which is pretty good. I'd also like a guy that can control the center ice position, and set guys up. We'd then have Scheifele and Duchene. I think if Duchene was not hurt and missed about 10-12 games, he'd be in the top 15 in scoring.( maybe top10) ??
With that said -Stone is no slouch as well, and I think he's somewhere in the top 20 in scoring, and his point per game is also decent. There's no doubt he'd be a big plus for the Jets, as their getting nothing from Laine. He doesn't look like a fancy player , skating wise, and play wise, as Duchene is, however he's one of those steady "big point producers" with great talent.
Adding either guy is a winning situation for the Jets , and I do have some reservations about what I hear about Duchene's character, and if he's trouble in the dressing room, your better off not to acquire him. These may be false rumors though, and he won't be causing trouble with guys like Buff and Wheeler around.
In summary -- I just think Duchene is a little more talented -- but I can't say if he's the better fit for the Jets. Chevy and management will decide that, but either guy is a big addition for the Jets. Both have great scoring numbers.
I have a "very strong feeling" that some kind of deal with the Sens is coming down. I guess we'll all wait and see.
______________________________________________________
Just my opinion- but I think to get a Duchene or Stone--the Jet's may let Roslovic go, or somebody good. They are going to have to offer something decent. They could throw in Mathew Perrault as well. I can't see them letting Laine go, at this time tho.
Would not surprise me to see Roslovic traded, to seal the deal. This would only be smart if you knew The Sens player will "resign" otherwise, not a good deal.
TheJadePipe
Registered User
- Mar 8, 2016
- 1,094
- 858
TheJadePipe
Registered User
- Mar 8, 2016
- 1,094
- 858
nobody imp0rtant
Registered pessimist
- May 23, 2018
- 10,938
- 18,279
Channelcat
Mennonite
Gabe Kupari
Registered User
Gabe Kupari
Registered User
Not smart at all to let Roslo go. Where will you get a potential Center replacement. Roslo might not become that but too early to give up on him.
I think Comrie, Petan, Stanley, a 1st and a 2nd should be enough. If you need to sweeten the deal throw in Perrault or Lemieux. You can even toss in Myers and move Poolman up. I'd even potentially replace Comrie with Broissot and ride Comrie as the back up.
_____________________________________________________
Good post--I think Roslo goes "for sure" for resigned Stone.
jokesondee
I’m not fat. I’m cultivating mass.
I'd do that in a heartbeat. Doesn't sound like enough though from a Sens standpoint.
Way overpay considering we will only get scraps for Trouba. not worth it. We can win without Stone.
folix
Registered User
- Jul 24, 2011
- 2,004
- 1,424
Its a over pay but its a good one. I would honestly make them throw in that AHL centerman everyone is high on as well. This works for both sides this would ONLY work for both sides IF Stone signs here.
jokesondee
I’m not fat. I’m cultivating mass.
I'd like it a lot more if there was a centre coming back with Stone if we are losing Roslo. Losing another 1st means we won't be able to draft one. Especially since I see us being taken to the cleaners over Trouba.
We would also lose Connor in bringing in Stone and I have high hopes for Connor.
could gain a Centre prospect & picks in an offseason trouba deal. im skeptical about Roslo being a c
Skeptical means there's still a chance. We will be taken to the cleaners over Trouba and return won't be half as good as we give for Stone.
- Jun 10, 2014
- 58,927
- 31,434
Dorion is trying for too much. Chevy will wait. According to the 'insiders' Dorion is also still trying to sign all of his UFA's. Don't know if there is anything to that or not. I think it is more likely just Dorion holding firm on his too high ask. He will have to budge when the deadline is close.
- Jun 10, 2014
- 58,927
- 31,434
I don't agree that Perreault has been bad this year. He has performed well in the roles given to him. But I'm pretty sure he won't be here next season.
I would not add him to a package that is probably already too high. I would swap him in for a lesser piece to improve the package. I think that would be an ideal way of giving it that last little push to get it done.
Is Nashville's offer of Tolvanen and a 1st much better than Ves and a 1st? Neither have done anything at NHL level. If we had to add you'd think it would be a small add. Say Perrault who would bring back a second in the off-season?
- Status
