Rumor: Rumors & Proposals Thread | Where's the Beef?

[Bryanbryoil]

It wasn’t just Strudwick. There were many posters on this board questioning his decision. Course we were told how the rebuilding situation in Detroit was going to ‘ideal’ for him and how he was finally going to a team where he was ‘wanted’. That lasted all of 33 games.

@McDNicks17 had a good post recently that summed it up well. There’s almost nobody on this board who didn’t like Kositin and want him back at reasonable money. But the reality is that other teams with more money to spend can offer overpays. It’s hard to put ourselves in a player’s shoes and say we’d leave money on the table. But it’s easy to say that after I took the money and went elsewhere, I wouldn’t come back to town, put on the Oilers jersey and pretend I’d always been loyal to the crest.

I don't blame Vinny or Kostin as they are both depth players and took roughly double what we would've offered.

 

[Drivesaitl]

I don't blame Vinny or Kostin as they are both depth players and took roughly double what we would've offered.

Exactly. How is this even an issue? Imagine in pro sports that players go for the money when they suspect their careers could be limited.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Exactly. How is this even an issue? Imagine in pro sports that players go for the money when they suspect their careers could be limited.

I remember the risk that Hossa took trying to win a cup. he took a cheap 1 year deal instead of a massive long term deal.

 

[Drivesaitl]

I remember the risk that Hossa took trying to win a cup. he took a cheap 1 year deal instead of a massive long term deal.

Good example. Not really comparable and probably pretty isolated. Still, nobody would blame him if he hadn't. Well maybe in Chicago.

 

[Took a pill in Sbisa]

I remember the risk that Hossa took trying to win a cup. he took a cheap 1 year deal instead of a massive long term deal.

I guess it's a bit easier to take on risk when you've got $40m in your bank account already

 

[Bryanbryoil]

I guess it's a bit easier to take on risk when you've got $40m in your bank account already

Much easier IMO.

 

[Jumptheshark]

Strudwick called this. He said it was better for his career to take less money and stay in Edmonton and continue to develop.

Here is the thing, The NHLPA are trying to stop players from taking home town discounts. Allan Walsh is doing a lot of grunt work behind the scenes to get all agents to press the players to get the most they can regardless of where

I remember the risk that Hossa took trying to win a cup. he took a cheap 1 year deal instead of a massive long term deal.

Hossa signed that 15 year deal where we all pointed to the exact moment he would go on the LTIR and he did

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

I remember the risk that Hossa took trying to win a cup. he took a cheap 1 year deal instead of a massive long term deal.

Hossa went short on term with Detroit but the one-year deal was $7.5 million ... in 2008-09. He tapped out with career earnings of $97 million. He got his Cups but Marion always collected his bank along the way.

No surprisingly young players who haven't achieved financial security opt for money first in their decision making. In some cases, they look for opportunity and the money follows.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Hossa went short on term with Detroit but the one-year deal was $7.5 million ... in 2008-09. He tapped out with career earnings of $97 million. He got his Cups but Marion always collected his bank along the way.

No surprisingly young players who haven't achieved financial security opt for money first in their decision making. In some cases, they look for opportunity and the money follows.

I just remember that it was a big discount and risk relative to his play at the time.

 

[McTonyBrar]

On Oilers Now, Bob Stauffer said he sees moving 2 second round picks and another pick as the way to get a top 4 Dman in Edmonton. He also said that he sees Philly and Columbus as likely trade partners and, perhaps, even a left handed Dman (who can play the right side) as who we may add.

That means Risto or Provorov at least for now

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

I just remember that it was a big discount and risk relative to his play at the time.

He had generational financial wealth secured already. The $7.45 million was still a raise from his multi-year Penguin contract at $6 million x 4. I loved the player but Hossa didn't necessarily sacrifice for a one year run in Detroit.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

He had generational financial wealth secured already. The $7.45 million was still a raise from his multi-year Penguin contract at $6 million x 4. I loved the player but Hossa didn't necessarily sacrifice for a one year run in Detroit.

Then I guess it was the risk of not signing long term. Yes he had a lot of wealth at the time but he was in his prime and how often did/o guys that were impact players at the top of their game take a 1 year deal?

 

[Bryanbryoil]

On Oilers Now, Bob Stauffer said he sees moving 2 second round picks and another pick as the way to get a top 4 Dman in Edmonton. He also said that he sees Philly and Columbus as likely trade partners and, perhaps, even a left handed Dman (who can play the right side) as who we may add.

That means Risto or Provorov at least for now

Whoever we get for that price better have some term at a reasonable cap.

Edit-Provorov is an UFA at season's end and Ristolainen has 2 more years after this one. So Provorov would likely be a pure rental. Olivier is an UFA at season's end as well. Man would I love to get him on the Oilers.

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

Then I guess it was the risk of not signing long term. Yes he had a lot of wealth at the time but he was in his prime and how often did/o guys that were impact players at the top of their game take a 1 year deal?

Selanne and Kariya. But again, it's a different risk tolerance with guys with financial security obtained.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Selanne and Kariya. But again, it's a different risk tolerance with guys with financial security obtained.

So 3 examples out of dozens or maybe even hundreds definitely shows that it isn't very common. A guy like Desharnais had to grab what he could because he was a very late bloomer.

 

[Behind Enemy Lines]

So 3 examples out of dozens or maybe even hundreds definitely shows that it isn't very common. A guy like Desharnais had to grab what he could because he was a very late bloomer.

All the younger ex-Oilers left to secure their financial security and for some opportunity was tied to the equation. Opportunity also present ability to chase financial security.

 

[harpoon]

I don't blame Vinny or Kostin as they are both depth players and took roughly double what we would've offered.

I never said any differently. My only problem with Kostin is that mere months later he was back in town wearing his old Oilers jersey while signed to another team. Clown move.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

I never said any differently. My only problem with Kostin is that mere months later he was back in town wearing his old Oilers jersey while signed to another team. Clown move.

I think that it was a nice move to show support for his old team but I wouldn't have been too happy about it if I was a Sharks player.