it’s clear that whoever is hired will be aligned with the vision but make no mistake Jackson is the architect, he’s drawing up the plans and making the decisions and the GM is the guy who’s just reading the blueprint and building it. Look at how Jackson has operated, he’s hired all the key players before hiring the boss. A new gm won’t be filling any of the critical roles with his own people, won’t pick his PD guy or his analytics guy or the guy heading up amateur scouting.
I wouldn’t be surprised if he picked an old guard guy who’s got the skills and experience of managing the day to day of the hockey ops and who’s been dealing with people in the league for a long time and has the connections but not as sharp in an evolved league compared to his heyday. And then he’ll pair that person with a younger, bright up and comer in one of the AGM roles who understands the league today and who will take over in a few years.
I don't see Jackson hiring an old establishment guy. The Oilers just had a Hall of Fame one.
He's been pretty clear about wanting a progressive thinker. NHL experience and familiarity but an innovation driven person embracing modern approaches to development, analytic supported decision making, sports science, contracts and cap management, etc. Strong communicator, negotiator, and consensus builder
It's just reality of the situation that Jackson had to hire this way and in some cases chose to make key management decisions for head coach; development; amateur scouting; and a legitimate analytics person. There's likely some latitude to tweak the existing assistant GM management team and support with holdovers in pro scouting; running the farm system; and capologist functions. A likely younger, developing GM prospect can view this both ways - as you describe or as an exciting opportunity to lead a newly formed strong leadership group with excellent specific experience and expertise.
Jackson is a progressive thinker with a growth mindset. He's moved quickly and decisively away from how this organization functioned under a traditional thinker. The GM gig is really an exciting opportunity to participate and lead in manifesting a well resourced best in class management group for a team with Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl pushing to win a Cup.