Speculation: Roster Building Thread VII (2019/2020)

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
  • We're expeting server maintenance on March 3rd starting at midnight, there may be downtime during the work.
Status
Not open for further replies.
oh I'm not saying its been a problem...I'm just saying, in theory, we can drastically improve our record play playing that top line a ton...but overplaying them isnt necessarily best for the team in the long run.

That's what Quinn is and will continue to do though.

He's trying to win. It's why Strome plays over other guys at 2C because he thinks the kids aren't ready. This isn't some motivational "earn it, kid" strategy. This is a guy who left his cushy college job to start an NHL coaching career trying to win.

So I have some bad news about TOI and all that impacting our record. David Quinn is going to try to impact our record.
 
That's what Quinn is and will continue to do though.

He's trying to win. It's why Strome plays over other guys at 2C because he thinks the kids aren't ready. This isn't some motivational "earn it, kid" strategy. This is a guy who left his cushy college job to start an NHL coaching career trying to win.

So I have some bad news about TOI and all that impacting our record. David Quinn is going to try to impact our record.

people said the same BS last year...it wasn't true then and its not true now.
 
It most certainly is true. Do you really think Quinn is going to ice a lineup that he is inferior thereby making his team worse and increasing the chances he will get fired before the end of his contract and hurt his chances at getting future coaching jobs in the league?
 
people said the same BS last year...it wasn't true then and its not true now.

Yes David Quinn definitely left his cushy college lifetime job to come to the NHL to rack up the worst 3-4 year record possible.

And he's doing so by sending all the kids to the minors and playing vets, because the kids would be too good and also because this is a master motivation strategy.

Not because he thinks the kids aren't ready to win games and he isn't interested in sending out a shit sandwich nightly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: egelband
I'm asking
He's a good lower lines winger. He doesn't play well for a defenseman playing wing, he plays well for a winger playing wing. He generates takeaways at a level people would be over the moon for if it were Chytil or Andersson, wins pucks regularly, and plays with an edge the roster lacks. Doesn't cough up the puck really either.

Probably more importantly he was told in the middle of a big multiyear tens of millions of dollar contract to not just change how he plays but change positions entirely and he's done it without complaint for a year. Lots of guys wouldn't have handled it that well (forwards whine about moving from center to wing all the time!) but he did. I'd imagine part of the promotion is recognition of that and a message to the room that you are rewarded for being a team player

They traded Namestnikov who was playing wing, so they need a wing. Who among Haley or McKegg would you prefer to play up on the third? Calling up Nieves to move Andersson to wing seems bad for a variety of reasons. Playing Nieves at 3LW instead seems worse.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: chitownranger35
He's also testament to Quinns MO.. If you work hard and do what is asked, you will play. Mistakes will happen but if you dog it and/or dont buy into the system, you're not playing.

With that said, I dont know what Lias needs to do. The great thing. he's reunited with Lemiuex.
 
The better question is without using any form of the term defenseman or discussion about his contract say what you do not like about Smith's play as a wing.
 
With that said, I dont know what Lias needs to do. The great thing. he's reunited with Lemiuex.
He needs to keep playing well and rise up organically, like thousands of rookies and second year players before him.
 
The better question is without using any form of the term defenseman or discussion about his contract say what you do not like about Smith's play as a wing.

He offers absolutely nothing offensively except for being decent on the boards, which is fine for a fourth liner, but as a third-liner, you should be able to produce on offense.
 
They traded Namestnikov who was playing wing, so they need a wing. Who among Haley or McKegg would you prefer to play up on the third? Calling up Nieves to move Andersson to wing seems bad for a variety of reasons. Playing Nieves at 3LW instead seems worse.

Panarin-Zbad-Buch
Kreider-Lias-Kakko
Lemieux-Howden-Strome
Smith-McKegg-Fast
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jackson Ranger
I would imagine David Quinn would love to have Jordan Greenway and Koivu would be great for Kakko. Koivu would be a great stopgap at 2C if the Rangers are in the playoff hunt and still lack a true 2C.
 
He offers absolutely nothing offensively except for being decent on the boards, which is fine for a fourth liner, but as a third-liner, you should be able to produce on offense.
How do you know he can't? Being on the 4th with plugs has been an excuse for a lack of production for Chytil and Andersson, but it's an indictment for Smith?
 
Riiiight, but not at the expense of wins.


Look, if Smith is some offensive dynamo, I'll be the first to eat crow, but I'm sorry, I don't see it
I see nothing wrong with giving him a game. It's not like the third line scores anyway
 
I would imagine David Quinn would love to have Jordan Greenway and Koivu would be great for Kakko. Koivu would be a great stopgap at 2C if the Rangers are in the playoff hunt and still lack a true 2C.

i think it would be a mistake giving up any assets for koive this year. and if we're in the playoff hunt, then the rest of the nhl is doing something wrong playing against us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad