Proposal: RNH For Your 3C and Spare RHD

[Treb]

The Habs will gladly trade you David Desharnais and Mark Redmond.
The Oilers won't be so glad, however.

Come on now, let's be generous and offer DD+Pateryn at least

 

[JohnnyJacket13]

Yeah that first deal shouldn't fly for the Oilers.

I hate the current Jackets approach of seeking grit and character over pure skill, but a 1-2 of Draisatl and Dubois followed by Jones/Werenski/Murray on the back end? Come on...

This is pretty much my line of thought. That's why I'd prefer the Wennberg+Savard for Draisaitl+Fayne deal to the Dubinsky+Savard for RNH+Fayne deal. The latter doesn't exactly solve our problems in the face-off circle, and is really a lateral move for the Jackets.

Wennberg+Savard for Draisaitl+Fayne, imo, would work out well for both teams.

 

[Sens of Anarchy]

Why would EDM want to trade RNH?

 

[leafsfan1234]

RNH and Oilers 1st for Bozak and Polak.

The 1st is to make up for how much better Bozak is compared to RNH.

 

[LTIR]

Post a link or shut up with this crap

https://mobile.twitter.com/The_STG/status/748526577630142464?ref_src=twsrc^tfw

I think Friedman tweeted it

 

[carter333167]

Oilers have looked good so far,

Granted, it's early, but I have a feeling it would take a sustained period of looking bad before they would trade a key player who is valuable in the current system for another key player who doesn't know the system.

 

[BudBundy]

RNH and Oilers 1st for Bozak and Polak.

The 1st is to make up for how much better Bozak is compared to RNH.

See what you did here OP? See? This is the kind of drivel that comes from starting a thread with a ridiculous premise.

 

[Basilisk]

Trevor Lewis
Matt Greene
1st round pick (2018)

 

[Crede777]

This is pretty much my line of thought. That's why I'd prefer the Wennberg+Savard for Draisaitl+Fayne deal to the Dubinsky+Savard for RNH+Fayne deal. The latter doesn't exactly solve our problems in the face-off circle, and is really a lateral move for the Jackets.

Wennberg+Savard for Draisaitl+Fayne, imo, would work out well for both teams.

You're only thinking from the CBJ point of view.

Wennberg + Savard for Draisatl + Fayne is poor value for the Oilers. The difference between Wennberg and Draisatl is much larger than the difference between Savard and Fayne.

Also I'd be shocked if Edmonton were even willing to entertain offers for Draisatl. They aren't.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Post a link or shut up with this crap

Several links have already been put up by Friedman stating that Shattenkirk wouldn't sign an extension in Edmonton. Hence the Hall for Larsson deal.

 

[tfantasy]

Nugent-Hopkins is not someone the Oilers should be trading.

This

 

[tony d]

Yeah, got to think Edmonton's going to be holding onto the Nuge.

 

[Homesick]

https://mobile.twitter.com/The_STG/status/748526577630142464?ref_src=twsrc^tfw

I think Friedman tweeted it

Its been debunked so many times

 

[McWeber]

Its been debunked so many times

Even though Stauffer and many others have been quick to dismiss the possibility of Shattenkirk being an option for the Oilers. Its not like he can come out and publicly say "I never want to play in Edmonton so don't trade for me". Trouba has never said he hates Winnipeg and yet everyone talks about the situation as if thats the main reason he hasn't signed yet. Sometimes you just gotta trust what the guys who are paid to know the inside information tell you. I would love Shattenkirk on the Oilers but realistically why would he sign here?

 

[Flameshomer]

Brodie for rnh

 

[OnTheBrink]

Brodie for rnh

You can't be a Flames fan... I hate the Flames but I have a ton of time for Brodie and would have to say yes to this. Neither team does this though, they are not trading significant players with each other.

 

[Rebuilt]

We arent trading any more core pieces at this time.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Its been debunked so many times

No it hasn't, Shattenkirk wouldn't extend with Edmonton this was from Stauffers very mouth coming from Shatty's agent whom is friends with Stauffer that Shattenkirk wouldn't sign long term there. It was suppose to be a deal around Hall for Shateenkirk and that's why Chiarelli dealt Hall to NJ for Larsson. Show a link stating that it's been debunked because you're wrong here hence the Hall for Larsson deal.

 

[Homesick]

No it hasn't, Shattenkirk wouldn't extend with Edmonton this was from Stauffers very mouth coming from Shatty's agent whom is friends with Stauffer that Shattenkirk wouldn't sign long term there. It was suppose to be a deal around Hall for Shateenkirk and that's why Chiarelli dealt Hall to NJ for Larsson. Show a link stating that it's been debunked because you're wrong here hence the Hall for Larsson deal.

show the link where he said this. I listen every day at noon to Oilers now and I keep hearing that he said this but never a a link provided

 

[nickschultzfan]

Answer has always been RNH for Dumba and Haula. Oilers would likely have to retain a bit of salary because they wouldnt be taking back much.

 

[McWeber]

show the link where he said this. I listen every day at noon to Oilers now and I keep hearing that he said this but never a a link provided

I can't find every instance where Bob stated that Shattenkirk is not a possibility so I would be shocked if you never heard it being a daily watcher. He was beating that drum for months though.

https://omny.fm/shows/oilers-now-wi...9-oilers-now-seg-1-bob-says-faulk-shattenkirk

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

show the link where he said this. I listen every day at noon to Oilers now and I keep hearing that he said this but never a a link provided

A link was just provided to you, Stating from Friedman that Shattenkirk wouldn't agree to an extension with Edmonton so Chia did the Hall for Larsson deal don't know what more proof you need.

 

[Homesick]

Answer has always been RNH for Dumba and Haula. Oilers would likely have to retain a bit of salary because they wouldnt be taking back much.

What else is MIN adding since Haula will be looking for a raise this summer and Dumba the following long before RNH's contract will be up

 

[AKL]

Answer has always been RNH for Dumba and Haula. Oilers would likely have to retain a bit of salary because they wouldnt be taking back much.

That's definitely not the answer.

 

[slg1963]

JT Miller and Girardi for RNH, there is your 3rd line center and a spare RHD