Depends on what you consider "Elite offensively". If you're looking for a Quinn Hughes or an Erik Karlsson, Seider and Edvinsson ain't it. But if Seider's shot continues to develop, he could very well end up a 10G - 15G, 50-60A guy as Detroit improves. Don't think Edvinsson's ceiling is quite known at this point.
I was pretty insistent there was no way Detroit was taking ASP. Granted, that was mostly arguing over #9. My whole argument was he doesn't fit what Detroit, or more specifically Yzerman, was looking for in a defensemen. After all, I think it was something like the Top 3 rounds he hadn't taken a sub 6 foot defensemen since Tony Deangelo.
... But in hindsight it makes perfect sense. Got a bunch of two-way giants on our blue line. Gotta change it up with the elite potential small PMD.