- Apr 16, 2012
- 4,743
- 5,912
If you can’t see how the Met, the American Museum of Natural History, the Guggenheim, the Cloisters etc etc etc are different from other cities I can’t help you. It’s subjective of course. If you don’t value that stuff then for YOU it’s not special. I’ll say it again because it bears repeating: many cities have something great, something they may be known for. But very very few have the WIDE range of outstanding features that NYC does. Parks, architecture, ALL types of culture, the financial sector, etc. NYC contributes more to the US GDP than all but three STATES, one of which is obviously NYS. hahaha. For instance Nashville has a great music scene, as does NYC, I go there for it, but nothing else there approaches NYC. DC has wonderful museums and history like NYC, the original Capitol city of the US, but the food and music scenes don’t come close. Just the fact of the matter. There’s a reason people flock here both to visit and to live. You may not be impressed with or like this city but it’s irrefutably special.So I never really got to respond to this because posting during the week is a futile effort with how accelerated work is:
I always use the disclaimer that I don't hate NY, I'm from here and I may seem or come off like a New York hater. When I say NY isn't special, honestly in the last 10-15 years, other than reputation, there have been like no improvements to the infrastructure or city over all. Look at places like Nashville, Austin, Milwaukee, they've all modernized. I always ask people what makes NY special now, what events, places, etc and they always refer back to nostalgia and pizzerias.
A lot of the ethnic restaurants in NY are available all over the country, microbreweries, etc.
The main museums and Broadway plays will always be there, but I don't see how they're different from other cities. You can find interesting stuff to do in every city. You can barely even go to a concert in Manhattan anymore. The real venues are in Brooklyn, Queens, etc.
Coupled with how expensive, hectic, and the whole "hey we're NY A #1" attitude with no factual evidence that much has improved in the last 10-15 years, it's still a big city, but not special or unique like it once was, especially for small town farm boys from Saskatchewan or NCAA prospects as UFAs.
Last edited: