When players are playing hockey after the middle of May, I never judge an individual's performance until the playoffs are over and we find out what they were struggling through. People were all over Bergeron last year and the SCF ended and suddenly people were like "oh he had a broken rib and a punctured lung?" Same thing with Chara. "Why doesn't he skate harder?" then "Oh, hip flexor?"
If Girardi is hurt, why the hell would he still be getting the minutes he is?