The thing is, hockey is a team sport and from my observation, it usually the team with the most heart, not the most talent that wins. Thats why depth is a topic of discussion come playoff time.
Crosby and Toews are wonderful captains and leaders. I have seen zero leadership out of matthews, marner, and nylander. They are closer to Kessel than Toews and Crosby imo. Look at the work ethic of hyman compared to them, he isnt the most talented but he tries each shift and cares. I cant see toronto ever winning with this core because they just dont have the right work ethic regardless if skill sadly.
Toronto tried to get them some mentorship with Marleau but that didnt last. Dubas gave the kids the keys to the castle and then was surprised when they through a house party instead of studying.