SettlementRichie10
Registered User
- May 6, 2012
- 10,200
- 8,412
And I listed three examples of guys who went on to have full recoveries.
Can you come up with some who didn't?
I'm not saying it's a good thing and he may well be hampered especially in the way Bandit points out we didn't draft him "just" to play, I'm just saying writing him off already is even more foolhardy when there are at least several examples of the opposite.
They've managed his injury for some time now. Jake Muzzin was out of hockey for over a year and a half. And that was more than a decade ago, would imagine they're better at back stuff by now.
Edit: and keep in mind my response was to such ridiculous statements as "you've seen the last of Vilardi" and "we're more likely to draft #1 overall than ever see Vilardi." I know we're bound to pessimism/cynicism around here, but good grief, write an emo song. It's like when people are presented with facts they double down on emotion.
I think people, including me, are buried under decades of justified cynicism with situations like these turning out good for the Kings.
The issue with Vilardi for me personally is moreso a sort of compounding anxiety:
- He dropped partly due to injury concerns to begin with.
- We know very little about the nature of his back issues. Is it a chronic, degenerative spinal issue? Is it just a series of injuries? Does he just need to build strength? None of us know, so it’s easy to think the worst.
- He misses virtually all of last season, and has missed multiple development camps in a row.
Players with Vilardi’s skillset almost never drop out of the top ten. Kopitar himself was probably the last player with that level of skill to drop that far in the draft. In Kopitar’s case, it was due to a bizarre fear of the unknown surrounding his nationality. In Vilardi’s case, it seemed to be a (thus far) valid concern surrounding his injuries, with general skating issues a secondary concern.
Until he shows up to a single development camp, can you really blame some of us for predicting doom and gloom here?
Lastly, I will say a healthy, full potential Vilardi would be an absolute boon for this franchise. Vilardi-Turcotte down the middle would be amazing, and vault us into significant contention if both Kupari and Kaliyev develop into top six wings as well.