Value of: Oilers 2017 unprotected 1st
- Thread starter Homesick
- Start date
McTrashBoat
Show me the deed
- Nov 28, 2014
- 9,536
- 3,078
Sojourn
Registered User
- Nov 1, 2006
- 50,523
- 9,377
The premise is a bit flawed. The value of the 1st varies greatly, even if you expect the team to miss the playoffs with their current roster. A team isn't going to want to move a good asset to the Oilers and cross their fingers hoping the Oilers suck.
What makes it even worse is that the team making the trade would be actively hurting their return by sending a good asset to the Oilers. Any asset that improves the Oilers means the trade is better for the Oilers, and worse for themselves.
What makes it even worse is that the team making the trade would be actively hurting their return by sending a good asset to the Oilers. Any asset that improves the Oilers means the trade is better for the Oilers, and worse for themselves.
Carolinas Identity*
I'm a bad troll...
last yrs team was in ploff contention until the last week of the season
we are not world beaters
but that is markedly better than w/e the **** you guys are
#NotTryingToBeRude
#JustCallingItLikeItIs
#NHL
#StickPuck
#WeProbablyDontDeserveATeamRight
LTIR
Registered User
- Nov 8, 2013
- 27,654
- 14,865
[/b]
last yrs team was in ploff contention until the last week of the season
we are not world beaters
but that is markedly better than w/e the **** you guys are
Les feeders de bottom!
Not sure why this thread has turned into a CAR vs EDM bashing contest.
hopefully both teams break out and make the playoffs.
The only way I'd trade and unprotected first is for Werenski plus or Trouba plus or a 1st plus from us for ekblad
Chiarelli rides into the press conference on a unicorn. Neither are likely to happen
Teams have done it before, it's not a ridiculous notion that it wouldn't happen again. A GM could decide that he'll value the Oiler's 1st as a 10th OV and base it off of that. It wouldn't hurt much for a rebuilding team like Toronto or Arizona to take that gamble if they have an expendable player.
Carolinas Identity*
I'm a bad troll...
Captain Controversy
Registered User
Boom Boom Apathy
I am the Professor. Deal with it!
- Sep 6, 2006
- 49,399
- 102,395
Ah, right forgot about that. I was thinking more in terms of towards the end of season/after the trade deadline/off season.
Jumptheshark
Rebooting myself
To Edmonton:
Mike Green
Oilers solve their 2nd pair RHD problem with a slightly overpaid Green(contract expires when 97 gets a McJillion per year)
To Detroit:
Oilers 2017 1st
Detroit solves their cap issues and adds a mid round 1st
Mike Green
Oilers solve their 2nd pair RHD problem with a slightly overpaid Green(contract expires when 97 gets a McJillion per year)
To Detroit:
Oilers 2017 1st
Detroit solves their cap issues and adds a mid round 1st
Carolinas Identity*
I'm a bad troll...
YakDavid
Registered User
- Dec 12, 2010
- 5,613
- 3,359
Here lies my problem in the thinking. If we get a piece like a 4 offfensive d, i think it makes us a rounded d which would make the pick worth less
There no deal to be had this early . If a team is trading the Oilers a good RHD they would have to think that pick is going to be in the 20s therefore they would want the Oilers to add . 10 years of sucking with 4 1st OA in the line up will make the Oilers management value that pick as somewhere around 10th to 15th OA if all things go right therefore they won't want to sell cheap on it until the players on the ice prove something .
Maybe a deal could be done closer to the trade deadline . The Oilers improve by 8 points last year and cut down GA by 38 with all kinds of injuries to key players . Problem with those injuries is we had no depth to really call anyone up that could be depended on . Chia has added a ton of depth since he has taken over just over a year ago . We are more able to handle injuries now than any time over the last 10 years . If we don't make the playoffs this year we are dam close to them . Cut down anther 30 goals GA and score an extra 20 and we make the playoffs . A healthy Klefbom and Larsson should cut down a lot of those . Lucic won't have the points Hall would but he will have the goals and McDavid will make up the difference then some . Eberle being heathy will probably add an extra 10 goals . So yeah if I am an GM of another team I don't make a trade for a decent PMD with out another big piece coming back with that first
Maybe a deal could be done closer to the trade deadline . The Oilers improve by 8 points last year and cut down GA by 38 with all kinds of injuries to key players . Problem with those injuries is we had no depth to really call anyone up that could be depended on . Chia has added a ton of depth since he has taken over just over a year ago . We are more able to handle injuries now than any time over the last 10 years . If we don't make the playoffs this year we are dam close to them . Cut down anther 30 goals GA and score an extra 20 and we make the playoffs . A healthy Klefbom and Larsson should cut down a lot of those . Lucic won't have the points Hall would but he will have the goals and McDavid will make up the difference then some . Eberle being heathy will probably add an extra 10 goals . So yeah if I am an GM of another team I don't make a trade for a decent PMD with out another big piece coming back with that first
The Oilers need to play the squad they have right now, see how it works out and what needs fixing. Right now you're just guessing based on what's on paper, but that is frequently very wrong.
I d think 10th pick will return a decent 4-5th rhd. 10th+2nd will definitely return a 20min 4th RD.
Hall > 10th, so I m with NJ fans with that value
So, you'd trade Dumba for a 10th( which could also be a 15th, or a 5th)? You'd be making EDM stronger, while MN old have to wait till about 2020 before they see any return( if any, 10th OA picks flame out all the time). EDM would then be in a better position to beat MN out of a playoff spot.
The trade to make this year was a Brodin/Scandella for Buff #1 this year, or for BOS #1 plus a Spooner.
No GM trades for a #1 that could be anywhere from a 5-15, unless there are other significant pieces involved, I.e. Dumba+ Haula for RNH+ EDM 1st.
Last edited:
And nobody is trading a top 4 RHD for a 16th, unless said player has age, contract, or injury issues.
I do agree with your point.
mashedpotato
full stack.
- Jan 10, 2012
- 2,153
- 385
What's the projected order for EDM's 1st?
Are they expecting to get out of the top 3 or is the club just a pile of hot trash again?
When is EDM expected to do something other than what they've been doing for the better part of a decade?
Depending on what the answer would be, I think that should be a gauge for what's coming back in the offer.
Are they expecting to get out of the top 3 or is the club just a pile of hot trash again?
When is EDM expected to do something other than what they've been doing for the better part of a decade?
Depending on what the answer would be, I think that should be a gauge for what's coming back in the offer.
