kanucks25
Chris Tanev #1 Fan
I think it's pretty evident in how McLellan reacted to that whooping by the Canucks...
It was not "more systems, more positioning, more film, more skill".
It was, "Battle Drills".
It's not the "sexy" thing like dangles, or the "statistical thing" like corsi...but hockey is still a game of battles. Physical battles. It's a physical game. Puck battles are the micro form of the game. It's extremely important.
Sbisa has some clear weaknesses (handling the puck under pressure)...but he has some clear strengths as well (he can skate with and hit with anyone in the league, and he wins puck battles, very consistently). Which is why i've said for a long while now...what he needs as a partner, is someone who can take those pucks he frees up, and transition them.
We really need Sbisa's physical ability to compete in the lineup, like it or not...the best situation is to find the right fit with him who can move the pucks he inevitably frees up and dribbles behind the net or whatever. Hutton actually showed some ability to do that, which is cool imo.
Who rolls with Hamhuis...i guess it's probably Weber, due to his RH PP shot...but i really don't like that much because Sbisa-Hutton is gonna be your "puck-moving offensive pairing". And Weber in any defensive situations is terrible. Corrado has fallen way short of the mark this preseason. Bartkowski has looked...promising, but also looked his worst with Hamhuis. So idk what you do. It's confused.
Try Hutton with Hammer and go back to Sbisa+Bart/Weber as the 3rd pair? Sbisa-Weber has always been a complete disaster. Bart-Weber couldn't move a gnat from the front of the net. We're probably missing a piece...
Here's the problem with what you're saying:
Sbisa's defensive lapses and overall horrible decision making are not worth his physicality. He is not the answer to our soft defense.
I understand physicality is important, but to me what really matters when it comes to D-men (or all players, I guess) is scoring chances +/-.
What does it matter if Sbisa can throw harder hits and cross-checks than other bubble D-men if he's a complete liability defensively? Being physical means nothing when you're constantly chasing in your zone and fishing the puck out of your net.
Considering they are probably both equally unreliable defensively, I'd much rather have Weber in the lineup because he adds the offensive element that Sbisa doesn't.