Most playoff games without winning the Stanley Cup:
1. Joe Pavelski 201 (21)
2. Patrick Marleau 195 (25)
3. Joe Thornton 187 (30)
4. Dale Hunter 186 (31)
5. Steve Thomas 174 (49)
6. Adam Oates 163 (69)
7. Brad Park 161 (75)
8. Brian Propp 160 (77)
9. Jeremy Roenick 154 (91)
10. Mike Fisher 146 (107)
Edit: Overall rank added. It’s fascinating to me that out of the top 100 in playoff GP, there aren’t even ten career losers. Of course with more opportunities, your chances at winning will increase. That makes these guys’ playoff careers even more depressing.
Marleau only missed the playoffs thrice in 23 years. 11 times his team didn’t get out of the first round, four times they made the conference finals, and once the cup finals. Hunter was somewhat surprising to see so high. I know he had a long career, but I didn’t think of those Nordiques and Capitals teams as particularly good particularly often. He did jump ship just before the Nordiques got terrible, though, and did make five runs to the Conference finals including the 1998 cinderella SCF run with the Caps, and his final season with the Avs in 1999.
Thomas is interesting as well. He played for six different teams, but kind of at the wrong times with exceptions. Joined the reigning champions Devils in 1995-96 when they’d go on to miss the playoffs. Was with the Keenan Hawks but not when they made the finals, but instead was with the Islanders when they upset the Penguins and went to the conference finals. Solid run that time where he was runner-up in team scoring. Made the finals once in Anaheim, played his last games with Detroit in the 2004 playoffs.
Adam Oates to me looks like a really solid playoff performer most of the time, it’s a shame he never got to win.
Park and Propp I reckon are two of the all-time unluckiest. Park made the finals three times, Propp a whopping five, and no cigar. Damn. Roenick, guess it’s his injuries and stuff, but he was a legit superstar early in his career and you probably figured he would get more chances at winning than he did. Made the finals in 1992, then had to wait 12 years for the next big opportunity, where the Flyers’ dreams ended one game 7 goal down vs eventual champs the Bolts.
Fisher feels like the springboard for the increasing randomness I expect will start to appear after the playoff GP top 100. Not a bad player, solid defensively, long career and was part of good Senators teams and the Preds’ run to the SCF. I guess he’s not that much more surprising to see than Hunter and Thomas, I just didn’t realize how long he’d been around and for pretty good teams.