This was a tough decision for me in the end - I hadn't thought it would be, but then my mind went into overdrive. I was imagining only having two bands and two albums to listen to forever, so in that headspace I Youtubed for quite a while. Ultimately, I don't think I could make a wrong choice, but here is why I settled on this, my original choice: variety.
From the early days, you have the hard-charging punk reggae that gets your adrenaline pumping. This was from the first or second album I ever owned, and I wore that motherf***er out.
I don't like the fourth album, "Ghost In The Machine," but it did have one of the most infectious songs they ever made, "Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic," on it.
"Do I have to tell the story
Of a thousand rainy days since we first met?
It's a big enough umbrella,
But it's always me that ends up getting wet."
Lovely. But the second and third albums are where we find one hidden gem after another. "Message In A Bottle" kicks off "Regatta de Blanc," and it's far from hidden, but it rules, obviously. Emblematic of the work on these middle albums is "Voices Inside My Head," off "Zenyatta Mondatta," where their musicianship is on full display. I'm pretty sure they already hated each other's guts by this point, but they were a super tight unit when playing. What an amazing atmosphere they created.
Then we get to their last album, "Synchronicity." It has probably the worst song I have ever heard ("Mother") on it, but is otherwise flawless. I've heard "Every Breath You Take" at least 100 times as many times as any of you have, and to this day I am still not the least bit sick of it. I still remember the first time I heard "King Of Pain" on the radio, right before I bought the album - it was a Saturday, and it blew my mind apart. Here's one that isn't as well known, but I can't get enough of it either. Listen to the beautiful guitar on this.
People have more f***ed up ideas about what this band was than you could shake a stick at. They were cool as shit. They ruled then and they rule now. In the pantheon and not far from the top.
Team Band II - The Police
@Hollywood Cannon