GDT: NHL 2023 draft 🎲 lottery 🎲 5pm PT, ESPN - Ducks will select 2nd overall

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

What's your optimism level – which pick will we get today?

  • 1st

    Votes: 34 33.3%
  • 2nd

    Votes: 17 16.7%
  • 3rd

    Votes: 34 33.3%
  • Corey Perry comes out of nowhere, screens Bettman, falls on him, and the lottery is postponed

    Votes: 17 16.7%

  • Total voters
    102
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s actually getting pretty irritating that big market orgs keep getting rewarded in the lottery. Especially Eastern Conference teams. Outside of the Edmonton BS from 10-15, a WC team has selected 1st 3 other times since the 05 lockout, one of which was Chicago with Patrick Kane. And we’re supposed to believe this is all fair as fair can be. Pfft.

/end rant

Now, bring on Fantilli!
 
I would have no problem if Fantilli went back to UM for another year and then signed with the Ducks after his college season ended. He is still very young and probably not NHL ready yet. And going to SD might really screw him up.
Doubt Fantilli spends any time in the AHL outside a conditioning stint.
 
Doubt Fantilli spends any time in the AHL outside a conditioning stint.
Like I said, he is still very young. Why rush him? PV seems to have that philosophy as well. We all saw what happened to Drysdale b/c they rushed him to the NHL.
 
You're being paranoid for paranoid's sake. It's not even worth entertaining the idea of him staying in college. There is zero upside for him to do such a thing financially or for his development.

If you can give me ONE good reason why an 18 year old who had one of the best rookie NCAA seasons ever and is projected to be the #2 pick would choose to stay in college until he's 22, then I'll accept it.
The path is open it can be taken. As long as its possible to take the path don't risk drafting him. Ducks are not a hot spot for players. We have already seen multiple players didn't want to play for the Ducks before. We don't even have a coach yet and might not have one by draft day which can effect his choice to keep playing college hockey at least for 1 more season.

If we do draft him when he hasn't committed to playing in the NHL right away I will immediately want a new GM and wont care what anyone says so don't bother trying, I wouldn't take the risk drafting him. We are not a franchise that should be taking risks like that. Call me paranoid if you want.
 
Bedard was always going to be the story of the night, but he was not the only story. And he won’t be the only story from this draft in the decade (or two) to come. A long way from it. And while there’s no guarantee that Fantilli will be the selection at No. 2 for the Ducks, who won the second draw (won, not lost, in case Ducks fans need that reminder!), he’d be my pick, I think he’ll be the pick, and today is a big, big day for that franchise. (There are, it must be said, scouts who’d stump for Russian winger Matvei Michkov, Swedish forward Leo Carlsson, and American centre Will Smith at No. 2, but Fantilli is still the consensus favorite and I expect that’ll hold through the men’s world championships and into draft day when push comes to shove.)

Though Fantilli hasn’t publicly stated whether he’s going to turn pro or return to college next year, and won’t until he sits down with the club that drafts him, the staff at Michigan are expecting him to leave and play in the NHL next year, that’s the sense I’ve gotten from those around him as well, and this men’s worlds with Canada should be a nice trial run for him to prove to himself, if nothing else, that he’s ready for the jump. I fully expect that he’ll pass the test and have an immediate impact in the NHL in the fall. It wouldn’t surprise me in the least if he and Bedard are two-thirds of the Calder Trophy nominees this time next year, either, though I think there are small-to-medium odds Fantilli, even if he’s in the NHL, could miss some time by going to play for Canada as their 1C at the 2024 world juniors in Sweden.

If it is Fantilli to the Ducks, I’ll be interested to see what that means for them at center, and where things shake out with Trevor Zegras (who seems the most likely to move to the wing given they’ve already used him there), Mason McTavish and co. That’s a very good problem to have in the end, especially when they’ve also already got a pair of premier D prospects on the way in Pavel Mintyukov and Olen Zellweger. The Ducks are in a good spot.

 
There's always a chance. Anything can happen. Ducks shouldn't take a chance on him if he isn't committed on playing in the NHL right away because he could go that route with it being open to him even if it seems unlikely he will take it.

Imagine drafting him and he decides to keep playing college hockey and then does pick his team to play for and it's not the Ducks how bad that would be for or the Ducks.
I mean any player can opt not to sign with the team that drafted them.

If fantilli forgoes signing he costs himself millions of dollars and time from a limited career. All while spinning his wheels because he’s been the best player in college hockey already for a year.

+I’m not sure how it works but would he have to find himself a new league to play in because he’s already done 1/4 of his university?
 
What happened to him? He got a fluke injury and just missed his age 20 season. You seem to be implying something that you have no idea about yet
He was not ready to play in the NHL as an 18 or 19 year old. He looked overmatched on most nights.
 
Columbus dropped. shocking the two small market teams dropped..

Thanks for the correction. It just seems like the Ducks are the one team that consistently moves down. I guess it's good they finished last because they were guaranteed a top 3OA. It's just a bitter pill to swallow after this crappy season.
 
The path is open it can be taken. As long as its possible to take the path don't risk drafting him. Ducks are not a hot spot for players. We have already seen multiple players didn't want to play for the Ducks before. We don't even have a coach yet and might not have one by draft day which can effect his choice to keep playing college hockey at least for 1 more season.

If we do draft him when he hasn't committed to playing in the NHL right away I will immediately want a new GM and wont care what anyone says so don't bother trying, I wouldn't take the risk drafting him. We are not a franchise that should be taking risks like that. Call me paranoid if you want.
Yes, you are paranoid. And you are saying we should never draft a college player again because they might not sign? Can’t do that.
 
Adam fantilli is Ian moores former teammate with the Chicago steel. Maybe he will convince him to sign.
 
I mean yeah you’re right but thrun is a chump and we’re not sure whether or not Moore is too so we have to give him the benefit of the doubt
I mean i dont even think it matters to much.... we got a lot of d prospects... and i imagine we will add another 1 or 2 this year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad