Proposal: Montreal Retool

[habs03]

Add a '21 2nd going to Montreal, add Greenway, take out Dumba, and you got yourself a deal.

Sounds good, minor adjustment though, add Alzner, remove Domi and we got a deal.

 

[le_sean]

Nah, hard pass on Domi for the 9th or Brodin or Dumba. We'll keep our assets, you keep the 50 point left wing that prefers playing center but got supplanted in the playoffs by two 20 year olds and is better on the wing but doesn't want to play there and also doesn't like the cold weather and will want to be paid like a 70 point center even though he's a 50 point winger.

I'll tell you what though, if y'all are really desperate to get rid of him, I'll do Greenway+'21 2nd for him.

Yeah it would suck to have a 70 point centre. Keep playing 49 year old Staal and the guy that has been traded 3 times in 4 years because he’s a failure as your top two centres.

 

[AKL]

Yeah it would suck to have a 70 point centre. Keep playing 49 year old Staal and the guy that has been traded 3 times in 4 years because he’s a failure as your top two centres.

Offer us a 70 point center and we can talk.

 

[le_sean]

Offer us a 70 point center and we can talk.

So I guess all of the score keepers lied about Domi’s points last year.

Meanwhile you’ll tell me how great Dumba is based on a year ago when all I see is a 25 point defender.

 

[the paisanos guy]

Domi's career totals put him at an average, a 55 point player so calling him a 50 point center is definitely wrong. It's something someone purposely trying to devalue a player would do.

I'm happy keeping him.

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

The Mete one the Islanders might do.

 

[HuGo Sham]

Take out Domi and add a top 6 center and we can talk about Brodin.

I'm hoping for Suzuki, maybe MIN adds pieces...

yeah keep f***ing hoping lol hope is good

 

[HuGo Sham]

Cmon don't be ridiculous, you know as much as i do Montreal isn't trading any of their young Center, unless an other good young Center comes the other way. It's the most valuable position and the team have struggled getting great C's for the past 2 decades.

kotkaniemi and suzuki are untouchables. period

 

[AKL]

So I guess all of the score keepers lied about Domi’s points last year.

Meanwhile you’ll tell me how great Dumba is based on a year ago when all I see is a 25 point defender.

I have no interest in trading Dumba for Domi, I have no idea what point you're trying to make

 

[AKL]

yeah keep f***ing hoping lol hope is good

I know lol, like the hope that Domi can get you a Brodin, or Dumba, or 9th overall

 

[HuGo Sham]

Remember when Poehling was untouchable? Good times.

shitty take. Suzuki and Kotkaniemi's sample size are much larger

 

[HuGo Sham]

I know lol, like the hope that Domi can get you a Brodin, or Dumba, or 9th overall

could care less. All i know is that with poehling, kotkaniemi, suzuki, danault, domi, evans ...teams will be calling.

 

[HuGo Sham]

Why the hell would you trade that much for Nick Leddy? He's bad. Kulak and Petry is also a really good pairing...

we wouldn't. it's an awful proposal

 

[le_sean]

could care less. All i know is that with poehling, kotkaniemi, suzuki, danault, domi, evans ...teams will be calling.

It’s okay. I’m sure he thinks they can trade Mikko Koivu and Greg Pateryn for Stamkos.

 

[HuGo Sham]

It’s okay. I’m sure he thinks they can trade Mikko Koivu and Greg Pateryn for Stamkos.

lol

 

[KaprizovEntitlelist]

Yeah it would suck to have a 70 point centre. Keep playing 49 year old Staal and the guy that has been traded 3 times in 4 years because he’s a failure as your top two centres.

One good season. Teams care about now, not past.

 

[KaprizovEntitlelist]

Any GM refusing Domi + 16OA for 9 OA is dumb, and MB would not propose this. Even if you believe he is only a 50 pt 2nd line LW, that brings you more than 7 spots at the draft I know MIN fans are fed up with Domi trade proposals for Brodin, but come on this trade is completely in your favour guys.
Always said I like Brodin a lot, I get why MIN fans want to keep him : so they can grow their army of 35+ year old player paid more than 7m (joking)

Only Montreal fans overrate Montreal, oi t think Minnesota should trade 9th overall. My gosh. Moving down isn't happening especially for domi.

You have right to your opinion, but your wrong. Teams don't trade top 10 picks especially when they can put together picks or other things to help them move uo

 

[Igor Shestyorkin]

we wouldn't. it's an awful proposal

It’s also helping the Islanders while MTL is a team that could and should take advantage of their cap crunch instead of helping them out of it.

 

[HuGo Sham]

It’s also helping the Islanders while MTL is a team that could and should take advantage of their cap crunch instead of helping them out of it.

as a habs fan, most of my fellow habs fans proposals are awful (but they're good people

 

[RationalExpectations]

Only Montreal fans overrate Montreal, oi t think Minnesota should trade 9th overall. My gosh. Moving down isn't happening especially for domi.

You have right to your opinion, but your wrong. Teams don't trade top 10 picks especially when they can put together picks or other things to help them move uo

2010 : CBJ trades 8 OA
2012 : CAR trades 8 OA, COL trades 11 OA
2013 : NJD trades 9 OA
2014 : OTT trades 10 OA
2016 : NJD trades 11 OA
2017 : ARI trades 7 OA
2019 : PHI trades 11 OA

I have arbitrary chosen 11 OA as a cutoff. Not saying MIN should or will trade, just saying that Domi to go from 16 OA to 9 OA is quite bad for MTL, if you take the value of a top 6 winger 50 point scorer as a UFA you re going to get late 1st + prospect so do you think any team would pay that price (and more because Domi is RFA) to climb from 16 to 9 ?

On another topic, what is MIN s plan for the future ?

 

[KaprizovEntitlelist]

2010 : CBJ trades 8 OA
2012 : CAR trades 8 OA, COL trades 11 OA
2013 : NJD trades 9 OA
2014 : OTT trades 10 OA
2016 : NJD trades 11 OA
2017 : ARI trades 7 OA
2019 : PHI trades 11 OA

I have arbitrary chosen 11 OA as a cutoff. Not saying MIN should or will trade, just saying that Domi to go from 16 OA to 9 OA is quite bad for MTL, if you take the value of a top 6 winger 50 point scorer as a UFA you re going to get late 1st + prospect so do you think any team would pay that price (and more because Domi is RFA) to climb from 16 to 9 ?

On another topic, what is MIN s plan for the future ?

Minnesota plan for the future isn't to rebuild. But our GM think different of Brodin; & Dumba then HFBOARDS.

Dumba or Brodin were never on market like Canadien newspaper and media exaggerated.

Much like the same with Foligno. It will have taken a 1st round pick to even convince Guerin to part with Marcus Foligno. I wasn't surprised though because in a way Guerin sees himself in Foligno

 

[le_sean]

One good season. Teams care about now, not past.

Well he was having a mediocre season and was still just 2 points behind your top centre who is 36 and not getting better.

I guess beggars really can be choosers.

 

[AKL]

Well he was having a mediocre season and was still just 2 points behind your top centre who is 36 and not getting better.

I guess beggars really can be choosers.

Not sure why you keep comparing him to our centers.

 

[le_sean]

Not sure why you keep comparing him to our centers.

To keep you talking.

 

[miscs75]

Can Mete play wing? The Isles need some NHL quality wingers.