Player Discussion Mitch Marner

  • Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
i love all our players but your going a little too hard for a player that disappears at the end of every series to down play a player that consistently gets the crums and finds a way to remain relevant yes marners a better defensive player for sure but i'll never forget that choke job against canadians with matthews as his centermen get out produced by willy with kerfoot and galy for christ sakes this might be the year we pull through but it sounds like your giving his 10.9 a pass when hes never brought it when it counted
It counted against Tampa in the first round when he was the star. But in a way you are right. Without Marner they would never have lost to Florida because they never would have made it that far.
 
Last edited:
It counted against Tampa in the first round when he was the star. But in a way you are right. Without Marner they would never have lost to Florida because they never would have made it that far.
he never brought it toward the end of that series either so i missed the joke
 
i love all our players but your going a little too hard for a player that disappears at the end of every series to down play a player that consistently gets the crums and finds a way to remain relevant yes marners a better defensive player for sure but i'll never forget that choke job against canadians with matthews as his centermen get out produced by willy with kerfoot and galy for christ sakes this might be the year we pull through but it sounds like your giving his 10.9 a pass when hes never brought it when it counted

nylander had 1 goal and 2 primary assist at 5v5 in his last 21 game ( thats including last 3 game vs mtl), so pleaee dont tell me he didn't chocking. At least Marner even if he didn't produce, he still help the team by shutdown top opposite player.

Barkov even if offensively, he didn't had amaizing stats last playoff... No body talked about him at all but he was probably the key piece of this team. We talked a lot about tkachuk, bobrovsky, verhaghe but if Barkov didn't shutdown aho, matthews and pastrnak line, it wouls be a completly different series. The soul of Florida panthers is not Matthew Tkachuk, its Barkov.

The only area nylander had better succes in playoff was on ppg and at 4v4... thats it
 
nylander had 1 goal and 2 primary assist at 5v5 in his last 21 game ( thats including last 3 game vs mtl), so pleaee dont tell me he didn't chocking. At least Marner even if he didn't produce, he still help the team by shutdown top opposite player.

Barkov even if offensively, he didn't had amaizing stats last playoff... No body talked about him at all but he was probably the key piece of this team. We talked a lot about tkachuk, bobrovsky, verhaghe but if Barkov didn't shutdown aho, matthews and pastrnak line, it wouls be a completly different series. The soul of Florida panthers is not Matthew Tkachuk, its Barkov.

The only area nylander had better succes in playoff was on ppg and at 4v4... thats it
heres the big question now who has he had the luxury of playing with and whats his toi average during this said amount of games
 
heres the big question now who has he had the luxury of playing with and whats his toi average during this said amount of games
stats at 5v5 last 18 games( would take too much time for last 21)

total pts
matthews 2.34 p/60 played
marner 2 32 p/60 played
tavared 2.68
nylander 1.39

tavares 1.2 goal/60
matthews 1.17
marner 0.84
nylander 0.23

primary points
marner 2.11
matthews 1.56
tavares 1.44
nylander 0.69

so marner had 3X nylander primary point and shutdown most of the time top.opposite line...
 
  • Like
Reactions: arso40
stats at 5v5 last 18 games( would take too much time for last 21)

total pts
matthews 2.34 p/60 played
marner 2 32 p/60 played
tavared 2.68
nylander 1.39

tavares 1.2 goal/60
matthews 1.17
marner 0.84
nylander 0.23

primary points
marner 2.11
matthews 1.56
tavares 1.44
nylander 0.69

so marner had 3X nylander primary point and shutdown most of the time top.opposite line...
doesnt that make it stupid to remove willy from the top pp if hes been the most productive since thats where hes getting his points and marner has not been in a shut down role we've been playing match up games tryna get them away from top competition but appreciate the stats though
 
nylander had 1 goal and 2 primary assist at 5v5 in his last 21 game ( thats including last 3 game vs mtl), so pleaee dont tell me he didn't chocking. At least Marner even if he didn't produce, he still help the team by shutdown top opposite player.

Barkov even if offensively, he didn't had amaizing stats last playoff... No body talked about him at all but he was probably the key piece of this team. We talked a lot about tkachuk, bobrovsky, verhaghe but if Barkov didn't shutdown aho, matthews and pastrnak line, it wouls be a completly different series. The soul of Florida panthers is not Matthew Tkachuk, its Barkov.

The only area nylander had better succes in playoff was on ppg and at 4v4... thats it
Believe it or not, certain posters here were proclaiming Marner was better than Barkov a few years ago. Yup, Eichel, Tkachuk, Barkov,, Aho, Rantanen. I believe some balked at Makar for Marner proposals. Nope Marner was easily the better player haha. Good times. Not seeing so much of those posts anymore around here. Then again, I was pointing out his shortcomings in 2019 when others were blinded by his stats with 27 year old, freshly signed John Tavares... who suddenly was the beneficiary to Marner, even though Tavares was coming off an 88 point seasons and being recently a two time hart trophy finalist on the island, while playing with little of a supporting cast. While Marner was coming off a 69 p69-pointson of... boosting 4th liners JVR and Kadri.
 
doesnt that make it stupid to remove willy from the top pp if hes been the most productive since thats where hes getting his points and marner has not been in a shut down role we've been playing match up games tryna get them away from top competition but appreciate the stats though

yeah i dont understand that part too on pp...

Marner every time keefe was able to send him against Kucherov line, he did it again and over again and Kucherov had been pretty quiet most of the time at 5v5. Against Tkachuk yeah you're right... they remove him from Tlachuk line to use oreilly physically against Tkachuk line.

but honestly i say it since 3 year now, the beet case scenario for me would be to get matthews marner and nylander own 3 different and now Matthews look like to have great chemistry with Domi. maybe its the best time to try until the end.

1A Bertuzzi-Matthews-Domi
1B Jarnkrok-JT-Nylander
1 C Knies/ holmberg-Marner
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: arso40
nylander had 1 goal and 2 primary assist at 5v5 in his last 21 game ( thats including last 3 game vs mtl), so pleaee dont tell me he didn't chocking. At least Marner even if he didn't produce, he still help the team by shutdown top opposite player.

Barkov even if offensively, he didn't had amaizing stats last playoff... No body talked about him at all but he was probably the key piece of this team. We talked a lot about tkachuk, bobrovsky, verhaghe but if Barkov didn't shutdown aho, matthews and pastrnak line, it wouls be a completly different series. The soul of Florida panthers is not Matthew Tkachuk, its Barkov.

The only area nylander had better succes in playoff was on ppg and at 4v4... thats it
And with Nylander, he wasn’t getting top competition 5v5 opposition, so his numbers are even more eye popping bad relative to Marner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: authentic
yeah i dont understand that part too on pp...

Marner every time keefe was able to send him against Kucherov line, he did it again and over again and Kucherov had been pretty quiet most of the time at 5v5. Against Tkachuk yeah you're right... they remove him from Tlachuk line to use oreilly physically against Tkachuk line.

but honestly i say it since 3 year now, the beet case scenario for me would be to get matthews marner and nylander own 3 different and now Matthews look like to have great chemistry with Domi. maybe its the best time to try until the end.

1A Bertuzzi-Matthews-Domi
1B Jarnkrok-JT-Nylander
1 C Knies/ holmberg-Marner

I think that would be good. Not to overplay any line and spread out the offense and create match up problems for opposition. And if we need to stack as an in-game adjustment if we are chasing the game we can do that too.

The only thing is that Leas/Keefe have consistently used Matthews-Marner as a defensive match up against opposition top lines with Marner being really solid defensively; so it would be a change from the past strategy (not that I will complain about it).

I would make one change though. I would swap Knies and Jankrok in the line up. Holmberg would need as much help at "C" and having Jankrok and Marner flank him would help him especially in the playoffs.

IMO Knies and Tavares have shown some chemistry so that would be good (remember the OT goal from Tampa series ;)).
 
Marleau's deal was for three years with a full NMC with large signing bonuses while the core were still on their ELCs, and it turned out to be a big mistake. Leafs should have no incentive to give JT anything like that.

I'm aware of all that, but he will also be 3 years younger and a better player than Marleau was at that point with a higher cap overall. If everyone is so confident he's signing for under 6 million I guess I'll believe it when I see it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 57 Years No Cup
10 points in 4 games, then 1 in the last 2.

He did his usual disappearance after game 4. 1 goal and 8 points combined in all games 5 through 7 of the 8 play-off series he's played. 8 series. 17 games. 1 goal. 8 points.
Matthews got 2 in the last 2, Tavares 3 and Nylander goose egged.
Hardly a disappearance. Despite being matched with the toughest opponents, he lead the team with a plus 9. Nylander couldn't even stay at zero
 
  • Haha
Reactions: arso40
Any official update on when we can expect a Marner return?

I like some of the post ideas that have him, Matthews and Nylander all on separate lines. Who knows, maybe Keefe will even try it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arso40
Marleau's deal was for three years with a full NMC with large signing bonuses while the core were still on their ELCs, and it turned out to be a big mistake. Leafs should have no incentive to give JT anything like that.

I don't know man. Tavares wasn't even in the picture when Marleau was signed.

Also, nobody expected Matthews to sign a 11.6 for 5 years and Marner 11 for 6 years. We all expected 8 year deals out of Matthews and Marner

I think the expectations at the time waas that Matthews would sign between 10M to 11M x 8 years (more than Eichel but less than McJesus for 8 years); while Marner would come in at around 8 to 9 mil for 8 years.

Matthews at the time would have been between McDavid and Eichel; and Marner would have been compensated the same as his comparables and 2 million more than Nylander.

But of course we know what happened LOL
 
10 points in 4 games, then 1 in the last 2.

He did his usual disappearance after game 4. 1 goal and 8 points combined in all games 5 through 7 of the 8 play-off series he's played. 8 series. 17 games. 1 goal. 8 points.
thank you which was exactly what i was getting at but anyways heres to changing the narrative
 
Any official update on when we can expect a Marner return?

I like some of the post ideas that have him, Matthews and Nylander all on separate lines. Who knows, maybe Keefe will even try it.

Marner was retroactively put on LTIR. I think the expectation is Wednesday against the Bolts. But not sure yet....

 
  • Like
Reactions: GrizzLeaf
And with Nylander, he wasn’t getting top competition 5v5 opposition, so his numbers are even more eye popping bad relative to Marner.
he also wasnt playing with the best goal scorer in the league or on the first pp like are you joking right now whos he passing the pucc to??cause i know marner wasnt scoring

Any official update on when we can expect a Marner return?

I like some of the post ideas that have him, Matthews and Nylander all on separate lines. Who knows, maybe Keefe will even try it.
level the playing field and force marner to be the scoring threat i know hes capable of being
 
  • Like
Reactions: GrizzLeaf
level the playing field and force marner to be the scoring threat i know hes capable of being

Marner is equally as capable as Patty Kane to be a scoring threat. He just doesn't shoot and it pisses me off.

I am more for Marner shooting; confuse the F outta the opposition and their goalies when they don't always expect a pass from Marner

just look at the game he got injured in. He didn't even shoot on the empty net; went behind the net to make a play and then took a nothing shot injuring himself.

Force Marner to shoot is the only way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OddyOh
Honestly, if MM performs in the playoffs, like dominate games, Leafs will go far. That’s a fact.
Problem is MM, AM, JT and Willie had not done that over the past 7 yrs. Only Reilly had done it consistently.
 
I know. It just another sports site with opinion. Not saying this about you but it certainly is a credible source to quote when someone is defending their favourite player
Tell that to @Notsince67, it was that poster who initially cited The Athletic as saying Marner brought over 3 million more in value than his 11 million salary.

In response, I asked that poster what year the article was, because just a couple months ago The Athletic asked the question whether Marners game had enough substance.
Yeah that's fair. I don't really get why anybody would use it to try and prove a point. I've seen people using Justin Bourne to even try and win arguments too in this thread. I probably should just stick to GDT's and cheering lol personally I have no interest in articles or analytics. Is Marner overpaid? I certainly think so in a hard cap league but he's definitely not the bad player everyone keeps trying to make him out to be at all and this talk about how he interviews and stuff just seems like extreme overreaching.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ACC1224
They need to be better defensively, solution = get rid of one of their best defensive forwards. :huh:
It's not a matter of "getting rid of" anyone, why do people keep trotting out that stupid straw man? It's about what could be done with the freed up cap space and let's say instead of Marner, we spent it on two Muzzin type Dmen, do you think there's a chance that overall, we'd be better defensively?

I suggest thinking before you answer, thinking a bit has been known to improve the quality of posts. ;)
 
Marleau was overpaid to leave his home and cap wasn't an issue until Dubas made it one.
You don't need to overpay a declining guy to stay at home.
Leafs have all the leverage with JT.
LOL no, not true at all, it was obvious to many of us that the 3rd year would be a problem the minute that contract was signed. There was LOTS of discussion about this that began the day the signing was announced and I'm pretty sure you were here at the time so it would seem that your memory is failling you on this occasion.

in regular season yeah, playoff is an other story.

Marner doesn't need great linemate, he had succes with everyplayer he playing with ( even with an old plekanec) + since he had 20, he played against top opposite matchup every playoff...


What making difference between team winning or losing is not skill or how long your attacking, how many figure skating you're doing in the offensive end... its how you defending, how many time you get back the puck on your stick and how hard you working. Marner drastically increase leafs in all those part of the game.
Nylander is actually the only one of our stars who's level of production does NOT go down in the playoffs so this is just wrong.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: authentic
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad