Yep. Now Marner is JT on NYI. We asked him to stay. We asked him if he doesn’t want to stay he can leave.
Now it’s all over.
If he doesn’t sign we have plenty to sign wingers.
Player Discussion Mitch Marner, Yet Again
- Thread starter SoupNazi
- Start date
Yep. Now Marner is JT on NYI. We asked him to stay. We asked him if he doesn’t want to stay he can leave.
Now it’s all over.
If he doesn’t sign we have plenty to sign wingers.
Why hasnt mitch signed then
Connor McDavid, Nathan MacKinnon and Auston Matthews top TSN's Top 50 NHL Player list | TSN
Connor McDavid is the NHL’s No. 1 player for an eighth consecutive season in TSN’s annual pre-season poll - the top choice on 20 of 20 ballots in TSN tabulations.www.tsn.ca
TSN who has long been accused of having a pro leaf bias, has Marner at 23 and Rantanen at 10. They have Matthews all the way up at 3. You may like Marner more than Rantanen but it seems the stats and the rest of the hockey world do t agree with you. This is good news, it puts Marner’s ceiling at around 12.5 x 8. We should be able to get him signed now.
Lets just hope his ego isnt puusified
Isn't it surreal to have a GM who actually knows how to hardball?
Ianturnedbull
Registered User
- Jun 11, 2022
- 6,532
- 6,034
I was convinced that Marner was going to stay and re-sign, but after hearing that Treliving made 2 attempts to get Rantanen I don't know anymore. It sounds to me like they're not close in negotiations. Paying JT, paying Marner, and paying Knies down the road means bold decisions have to be made.
We will be just fine brother.
It will hurt losing Marner for nothing, for all his faults hes a solid hockey player. But there's also something to be said around cup teams and their culture. Marner can never be a culture guy with his me first attitude.
Matthews is in a similar boat but the guy has legendary potential. You absolutely buck up and pay for that. Marner, while being ultra skilled, is not as rare of a talent as Matthews. Just imagine what tre can do with an extra 11Mil to our D, we could really be turning the corner here into a stalwart defensive group.
ToneDog
56 years and counting. #FireTheShanaClan!
This is more proof that Marner's ask is ridiculous, even to the Leafs.
666
Registered User
- Jun 27, 2005
- 3,324
- 1,081
I'll bite. Show me proof of the number and term that Marner is asking. Then show me proof not some journalists opinion of the number and term that the Leafs are offering. You guys are getting all wound up over rumours and journalists making shit up or being used by both sides in the negotiations. Also, it's very probable that Marner will go to UFA as is his right. Why are you exhausting yourself over rumours.
Wish we held onto Lou for the "contracts".
Marners camp still talks about those performance bonuses
Menzinger
Kessel4LadyByng
True. Which is why I always roll my eyes at the whole 'Mitch is just a home town kid who loves the coty' stuff. He's being driven by money. Which doesn't make him a bad guy,.hockey is a business, but it also doesn't mean fans have to like it.
Funnily his biggest money offers from other teams are likely going to be from non-playoff teams. Chicago/Pittsburgh /New York/Anaheim also have state income taxes so there goes the narrative that the Leafs have to grossly overpay to compensate for taxes
Do you not remember last time?
This will go on until right up to July 1. Ferris is a field rat.
PanniniClaus
Registered User
- Oct 12, 2006
- 12,738
- 6,059
This is just fine. Marner is now under tremendous pressure to perform and that can only help our chances of winning a cup. If he does what he normally does, he costs himself millions and we aren't on the hook for yet another albatross contract. He's the one taking the gamble.
Divine
Registered User
- Dec 18, 2010
- 20,342
- 14,872
The problem is the only person you listen to is Marner. Multiple sources saying the Leafs offered Marner more than Rantanen signed for, it doesn't matter.
Do you expect Marner to come out and say I want 13M+? Why would he say that? Would he enjoyed getting booed the rest of the season?
The Shadow
Registered User
- Feb 9, 2013
- 1,729
- 1,835
Both Vladdy (Jays) and Marner will be leaving Toronto this year
But that’s a lot of cap space that can be used towards another target that may be a better fit for what Brad wants to do.
But that’s a lot of cap space that can be used towards another target that may be a better fit for what Brad wants to do.
If you don't think he's demanding 13 plus I got a bridge to sell you
666
Registered User
- Jun 27, 2005
- 3,324
- 1,081
"Multiple sources" is all that you should need to hear to dismiss it. Marner deserves more than Rantanen. Marner and his agent would never publicly announce their offers but both sides might use the media to negotiate.
666
Registered User
- Jun 27, 2005
- 3,324
- 1,081
Menzinger
Kessel4LadyByng
What proof do you have they're making any of this up?
Common sense and reading between the lines of what's been reported would suggest the Leafs have likely made a fairly generous offer to Marner without knowing every single detail.
Do you honestly think the Leafs haven't offered him more money than say Nylander?
Like really though. What does this guy want.
Can someone please list out a deal that makes sense for both Toronto and Marner? I honestly cant do it if its not 12.5 x 8, and im not really sure that makes sense for us.
It’s not the end of the world if he walks for nothing. A deadline trade may have gotten 2 1sts, look what we got for 2 1sts. It was something but we wouldn’t be crushed without Laughton and Carlo.
Fogelhund
Registered User
- Sep 15, 2007
- 24,574
- 29,778
If he wasn't willing to sign to a decent deal that works for the Leafs, then we really should just wait and see how the playoffs go. If we fail to succeed, and as usual he's a big part of that failure, we are probably better re-allocating that cap elsewhere anyway. We can't keep doing the same thing, and expecting different results... at some point we are going to have to change it up.
djdev
Registered User
also marners contract history here..another important piece of information
I think we just consider Marner a rental and just go balls to the wall. We use our 10mil + 11 (JT) + 12 (Marner) and we retool.
Unfortunately Bennett is a Ferris client, hopefully we can nab a 2c, 2LW and another solid dman on July 1. We will be in a good position if so.
Unfortunately Bennett is a Ferris client, hopefully we can nab a 2c, 2LW and another solid dman on July 1. We will be in a good position if so.
Superstar
"Be water, my friend."
- Jun 25, 2008
- 12,865
- 9,249
Matthews actually. Same comparable he demanded for his last contract too.
Difference is we having a GM who's calling him out on his bullshit.
Menzinger
Kessel4LadyByng
Yep.
And ther e also been other reporting than beside the stuff that's come out the past 48H
The idea that all of a sudden all of Canada's hockey media has decided to make stuff up collectively about Marner and his current negotiations is nonsense
