- Dec 10, 2012
- 40,560
- 18,899
Guerin has had the 19-20, 20-21, 21-22, and 22-23 seasons. I’m not saying 6-7 years for a prospect to develop. I’m saying 6-7 years of him drafting players and building a pool of players that can be impactful.
Well the first thing to address here is I never claimed Guerin was a good GM.
Second thing is his first draft was 2020, which is THREE calendar years ago, and FOUR drafts ago, so if your expectation is that his pool starts contributing in 6-7 years, that would be around 2026-2027.
If you're consistently drafting in the middle/late part of the first round, you're not going to get many players who make an impact 2-4 years after they were drafted. Same goes for anyone in the second round. These guys often take 5-7 years to be actual impact (read: top six or top four) players in the NHL, if they ever get there.
So you can't make a blanket statement like "he's been drafting for 6-7 years, so SOMEONE should be an impact player by now" because 1) he hasn't been drafting for 6-7 years and 2) not all of the players came into the pool at the same time 6-7 years ago.
At best, by 2025-26, the last year of Kaprizov's contract, we could expect maybe 2-3 top six/top four players out of our current pool (thinking like Faber, Khusnutdinov/Rossi, maybe Yurov)? And those aren't even necessarily top line/top pairing expectations. We're not drafting MacKinnons, Makars and Rantanens here. We have a pool full of middle of the lineup guys. That means we're still going to be relying on Kaprizov, Ek and Boldy more than anyone else. Maybe we get lucky and Yurov is a first liner a la Boldy four years after his draft.