Mike Bossy vs Pavel Bure who's the better goal scorer all time?

Who's the better goal scorer all time Mike Bossy or Pavel Bure?

  • Mike Bossy

    Votes: 88 81.5%
  • Pavel Bure

    Votes: 20 18.5%

  • Total voters
    108

sr edler

gold is not reality
Mar 20, 2010
12,140
6,626
Great rebuttal.

You didn't bring anything new or interesting to the table, to rebut. It's the same old tired "I think Bure couldn't play under this coach because style" and "I don't think Bure could have had chemistry with Zhamnov because reasons" hypotheticals.
 

BarnabyJones PI

I'd kindly settle for a tall glass of milk.
You didn't bring anything new or interesting to the table, to rebut. It's the same old tired "I think Bure couldn't play under this coach because style" and "I don't think Bure could have had chemistry with Zhamnov because reasons" hypotheticals.
Yet here you are, inserting yourself again, as you have in many similar threads (over the years) on the subject of Bure's style of play. I know I don't bother jumping in on discussions/debates over something I find "tiresome".
 

overpass

Registered User
Jun 7, 2007
5,555
3,907
Ottawa, ON
For those who are comparing stats between Bure and Bossy, I brought up the difference in ice time, where Bure played significantly more ice time than Bossy in his peak goal scoring years. I've gone through a game for each of them and actually tracked the ice time. In each of the games I chose, Bure and Bossy scored a hat trick. Bure played 32 minutes in the game, and Bossy played 16 minutes.

Mike Bossy
I chose Game 4 of the 1983 series against the Boston Bruins, which the Islanders won 8-3, scoring 5 goals in the third period to blow out the Bruins. Bossy scored goals to make it 3-2, 4-2, and 6-2.




Here are Bossy's shifts.

PlayerPeriodStart of shiftEnd of shiftShift lengthState
Mike Bossy
1​
20:00​
19:17​
0:43​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
15:39​
14:14​
1:25​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
11:42​
10:42​
1:00​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
9:56​
9:10​
0:46​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
3:53​
3:13​
0:40​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
2:23​
1:11​
1:12​
PP
Mike Bossy
2​
20:00​
19:00​
1:00​
PP
Mike Bossy
2​
17:01​
15:55​
1:06​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
13:53​
12:43​
1:10​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
11:32​
9:52​
1:40​
PP
Mike Bossy
2​
6:48​
6:01​
0:47​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
4:10​
3:10​
1:00​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
0:50​
0:00​
0:50​
EV
Mike Bossy
3​
20:00​
19:07​
0:53​
EV
Mike Bossy
3​
17:07​
16:47​
0:20​
EV
Mike Bossy
3​
13:36​
12:32​
1:04​
PP/EV
Mike Bossy
3​
9:36​
9:02​
0:34​
EV

PlayerPeriodShiftsTOI
Mike Bossy
1​
6​
5:46​
Mike Bossy
2​
7​
7:33​
Mike Bossy
3​
4​
2:51​
Mike BossyTotal
17​
16:10

Overall, Bossy played 17 shifts, totalling about 16 minutes of time on ice. He didn't play a shift in the last 9 minutes of the game, when the Islanders already had 8 goals and a 5-6 goal lead. He was fourth in ice time among Islander forwards, behind Bryan Trottier (20:08), Bob Nystrom (17:36), and Bob Bourne (17:31).

And here are Bossy's three goals.

First goal by Bossy, a between-the-legs pass from Anders Kallur on the rush beat both Boston D-men, and Bossy beat Peeters with a quick shot.

Second goal by Bossy shows his absurdly quick release as he skated to the high slot and one-timed a saucer pass from the corner.

Third goal by Bossy. Potvin hit him with a pass for a breakaway on the power play. Bossy tucked it under Peeters while being hooked from behind and turned around. The announcers were just trashing Peeters for his poor lateral movement by this time,

Pavel Bure

I tracked Bure's ice time for a Toronto-Florida regular season game on March 17, 2001. Bure scored all three goals in a 5-3 loss to Toronto.





Here are Bure's three goals. First, second, third. On all three goals, he received a pass with speed in the neutral zone, skated over the blue line, and beat Curtis Joseph with a shot taken at speed.

Here are Bure's shifts.

Player
Period
Start of shift
End of shift
Shift length
State
Pavel Bure
1​
20:00​
19:10​
0:50​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
18:00​
16:30​
1:30​
PP
Pavel Bure
1​
14:45​
14:38​
0:07​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
12:20​
9:55​
2:25​
EV/PP
Pavel Bure
1​
7:00​
5:20​
1:40​
SH/EV
Pavel Bure
1​
4:25​
3:45​
0:40​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
2:40​
1:58​
0:42​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
0:48​
0:00​
0:48​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
20:00​
19:00​
1:00​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
17:50​
16:40​
1:10​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
15:30​
14:03​
1:27​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
13:17​
11:33​
1:44​
PP
Pavel Bure
2​
10:10​
8:05​
2:05​
EV/PP
Pavel Bure
2​
6:40​
5:23​
1:17​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
5:10​
4:40​
0:30​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
3:04​
2:05​
0:59​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
1:05​
0:00​
1:05​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
20:00​
18:55​
1:05​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
18:24​
15:34​
2:50​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
14:52​
14:20​
0:32​
SH
Pavel Bure
3​
13:05​
11:23​
1:42​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
10:10​
8:45​
1:25​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
8:00​
6:55​
1:05​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
5:41​
2:50​
2:51​
PP/EV
Pavel Bure
3​
1:25​
0:07​
1:18​
EV


Player
Period
Shifts
TOI
Pavel Bure
1​
8​
8:42​
Pavel Bure
2​
9​
11:17​
Pavel Bure
3​
8​
12:48​
Pavel Bure
Total​
25​
32:47​

Overall, Bure played 25 shifts, totalling about 32 minutes of ice time, which was first on the Panthers. He played his most minutes in the third period, almost 13 of 20 minutes.

So we all know Bossy had some advantages. Better teammates and playmakers to set him up. He played in a higher scoring era against worse goalies. But he also had to play within a team system that was focused on winning. Many other great goal scorers would be out there in the last 10 minutes of the game trying to score more. And in the case of Bossy and Bure specifically, Bure played much more ice time.
 

overpass

Registered User
Jun 7, 2007
5,555
3,907
Ottawa, ON
Since I tracked the ice time numbers for all the Islander forwards in 1983, Game 4 vs the Bruins, I'll post them here.

PlayerPosTOIEVTOIPPTOISHTOI
Bryan TrottierC
20:08​
12:13​
4:07​
3:48​
Bob NystromRW
17:36​
17:36​
0:00​
0:00​
Bob BourneLW
17:31​
11:17​
2:54​
3:20​
Mike BossyRW
16:10​
12:03​
4:07​
0:00​
John TonelliLW
14:34​
14:34​
0:00​
0:00​
Duane SutterRW
13:34​
10:40​
2:54​
0:00​
Brent SutterC
13:24​
10:30​
2:54​
0:00​
Butch GoringC
12:46​
9:33​
0:00​
3:13​
Anders KallurLW/RW
12:42​
10:05​
1:57​
0:40​
Clark GilliesLW
11:52​
9:42​
2:10​
0:00​
Billy CarrollLW/C
9:06​
3:08​
0:00​
5:58​
Wayne MerrickC
8:56​
8:56​
0:00​
0:00​

PlayerPosP1 TOIP2 TOIP3 TOITOI
Bryan TrottierC
9:22​
7:33​
3:13​
20:08​
Bob NystromRW
3:40​
6:51​
7:05​
17:36​
Bob BourneLW
6:54​
5:48​
4:49​
17:31​
Mike BossyRW
5:46​
7:33​
2:51​
16:10​
John TonelliLW
4:10​
5:41​
4:43​
14:34​
Duane SutterRW
3:14​
5:36​
4:44​
13:34​
Brent SutterC
3:14​
5:36​
4:34​
13:24​
Butch GoringC
4:51​
5:16​
2:39​
12:46​
Anders KallurLW/RW
1:08​
6:13​
5:21​
12:42​
Clark GilliesLW
5:04​
2:18​
4:30​
11:52​
Billy CarrollLW/C
3:15​
0:00​
5:51​
9:06​
Wayne MerrickC
3:22​
1:35​
3:59​
8:56​

I've said before that Isles coach Al Arbour "rolled" four lines. That's not quite accurate for this game, he was closer to rolling 3 lines, and only got about 2 shifts per period for the fourth line. But he did use all 12 forwards. He wasn't afraid to skip a line when needed or double shift a player, and as the game went on he moved his depth forwards up and got ice time for everyone.

Arbour was hardly the only coach to take a balanced approach to ice time, or to include all 12 forwards. But not so many coaches with a dominant duo like Trottier and Bossy have exercised this much restraint in their minutes played.

Period 1: EV lines were
Gillies-Trottier-Bossy
Tonelli-Merrick-Nystrom
Bourne-B.Sutter-D.Sutter
Carroll-Goring-Kallur (rarely played at EV, Goring played a lot of SHTOI)

Period 2 and first half of period 3: EV lines were
Kallur-Trottier-Bossy
Tonelli-Goring-Nystrom
Bourne-B.Sutter-D.Sutter
Gillies-Merrick-Carroll (Gillies and Merrick got three shifts with Nystrom double shifting, Carroll didn't play)

Second half of period 3
Tonelli-Merrick-Nystrom
Bourne-B.Sutter-D.Sutter
Gillies-Carroll-Kallur
Trottier, Bossy, Goring didn't play

Bryan Trottier - started off as the #1 in all situations. Lots of SHTOI in the first period. Also went out for brief shifts to take faceoffs and get off the ice. Played his last EV shift with 11 minutes to go and a six goal lead, and didn't play at all after a PK shift with 7 minutes to go.

Mike Bossy - played on the top line and the top PP unit. Always with Trottier until his final shift with 9 minutes to go. The top PP unit with Bossy and Trottier played only 60% of the PP minutes, and on two occasions the second unit started the PP.

Bob Nystrom - one of Arbour's key EV matchup forwards, he played more than any other Islander forward at EV and double shifted occasionally.

John Tonelli - Another key matchup forward at EV, played with Nystrom. They were sometimes centred by Butch Goring and sometimes by Wayne Merrick.

Bob Bourne - played on the third line and the second PP unit with Brent and Duane Sutter, and the second PK unit with Billy Carroll.

Duane and Brent Sutter - played every shift together, at EV or on the PP, almost always with Bob Bourne.

Butch Goring - Played on the top PK unit with Trottier.

Wayne Merrick - Played EV only, splitting time with Goring on the key matchup line with Tonelli and Nystrom.

Anders Kallur - Rarely played in the first, got regular shifts in the second and third, including playing half the game on Trottier and Bossy's LW.

Clark Gillies - Played on Trottier and Bossy's wing in the first period. Dropped to the fourth line in the second period and rarely played, got regular shifts again in the last 10 minutes.

Billy Carroll - Didn't play an EV shift in the first two periods, he was only used on the second PK unit with Bourne. Played EV shifts after the game was in hand in the third period, and also played most of the PK time in the third, including as the lone forward as a 5-on-3 after the game was out of reach.
 
Last edited:

BraveCanadian

Registered User
Jun 30, 2010
15,375
4,666
Might be worthwhile to compare a couple of close games with the same result for their teams.

No doubt Florida Bure played more than Bossy in general but in that 8-3 game Trottier and Bossy obviously got idled down for a game that was well in hand.

Bure on the losing end probably played a bit more then normal trying to catch up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wetcoast

Cursed Lemon

Registered Bruiser
Nov 10, 2011
11,524
6,110
Dey-Twah, MI
Saying Bure was a better goalscorer is not the same thing as saying he was a better player and I think that's getting lost on some people here.
 

overpass

Registered User
Jun 7, 2007
5,555
3,907
Ottawa, ON
Might be worthwhile to compare a couple of close games with the same result for their teams.

No doubt Florida Bure played more than Bossy in general but in that 8-3 game Trottier and Bossy obviously got idled down for a game that was well in hand.

Bure on the losing end probably played a bit more then normal trying to catch up.

Yes, the two games were certainly not apples and oranges. Although Bure still played more than 50% higher ice time than Bossy in the first two periods.

I've tracked ice time for another Islander game. This time for Game 4 of the 1981 Stanley Cup Finals against Minnesota. The game was within a goal throughout and the Islanders trailed by a goal for most of the third period.

Bossy played only 17:03 in this close game.




1000002906.png



1000002907.png



1000002908.png



This game was before rosters were expanded to 18, so there were only 11 forwards. Billy Carrol and Duane Sutter were the 10th and 11th forwards, and played almost no EV time in the first two periods. What's interesting is that Al Arbour lengthened instead of shortened his bench in a close third period game, and gave Sutter and Carroll two shifts with Nystrom. Trying to win with fresh legs instead of by loading up on ice time for the stars.

Tonelli-Merrick-Nystrom had no special teams roles so they took the first shift of every period and the shift after power plays for either team. On at least two occasions they played a full EV shift and then went out for another shift after a 30 second TV timeout.

Trottier played with Bossy for 15 of Bossy's 16 shifts, and then played another 10 shifts for a total of 25. All were either shorthanded shifts (sometimes two in one penalty if there was a faceoff) or going out for a defensive zone faceoff and then getting off at the next opportunity. Oddly enough, Trottier didn't take those EV faceoffs, he played as a winger, replacing Tonelli, Bourne, or Kallur, but never Nystrom. Merrick or Goring still took the faceoff. And Trottier got off at the first opportunity.

Trottier clearly had a bigger defensive role than Bossy. But I think Bossy was just as clearly the better offensive player, and an underrated all time great. He was an exceptional goal scorer, with a lightning quick release, and very good at finding space in the slot or going to the front of the net.

Beyond his shooting, Bossy was also very effective all over the offensive zone at quickly moving the puck to teammates and making the right decision, and rarely turned the puck over. And he engaged in as many board battles as his linemates, he didn't drift around waiting for them to do the work. He wasn't a playmaking winger who held the puck a lot to make the final pass, but his quick puck movement and smart decisions combined with his all time great finishing helped make his team extremely dangerous offensively whenever he was on the ice.
 
Last edited:

VistamarCroissants

Registered User
Apr 19, 2024
85
60
This is usually a big deal, but Bossy-Bure you can more do it career vs career because they both did not play much post drop, one season for Bossy, not sure for Bure.

Even if Bure played a lot of his game in good scoring environnemnt (92-93-94-95) I would imagine Bossy played in general in the highest time ever in that regard too.

Bure excelled in a much more competitive league than Bossy.

So the answer is Bure.
 

MadLuke

Registered User
Jan 18, 2011
10,766
6,259
Bure excelled in a much more competitive league than Bossy.
But Bossy did really well in the playoff (and in the playoff against the very solid team), against the good team during the regular season and best on best tournament, both proved themselves to be good in high level hockey, I am not sure we can give much an edge to the other in that regard.

They were clearly both able to score in any league, any type of hockey, very natural goal scorer, their result not base on a favorable situation or how hockey was played when they did.

If we keep it how they did against Canadians goalscorer only in the nhl, there is not much of a big gap either way.
 

wetcoast

Registered User
Nov 20, 2018
24,825
11,665
For those who are comparing stats between Bure and Bossy, I brought up the difference in ice time, where Bure played significantly more ice time than Bossy in his peak goal scoring years. I've gone through a game for each of them and actually tracked the ice time. In each of the games I chose, Bure and Bossy scored a hat trick. Bure played 32 minutes in the game, and Bossy played 16 minutes.

Mike Bossy
I chose Game 4 of the 1983 series against the Boston Bruins, which the Islanders won 8-3, scoring 5 goals in the third period to blow out the Bruins. Bossy scored goals to make it 3-2, 4-2, and 6-2.




Here are Bossy's shifts.

PlayerPeriodStart of shiftEnd of shiftShift lengthState
Mike Bossy
1​
20:00​
19:17​
0:43​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
15:39​
14:14​
1:25​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
11:42​
10:42​
1:00​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
9:56​
9:10​
0:46​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
3:53​
3:13​
0:40​
EV
Mike Bossy
1​
2:23​
1:11​
1:12​
PP
Mike Bossy
2​
20:00​
19:00​
1:00​
PP
Mike Bossy
2​
17:01​
15:55​
1:06​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
13:53​
12:43​
1:10​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
11:32​
9:52​
1:40​
PP
Mike Bossy
2​
6:48​
6:01​
0:47​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
4:10​
3:10​
1:00​
EV
Mike Bossy
2​
0:50​
0:00​
0:50​
EV
Mike Bossy
3​
20:00​
19:07​
0:53​
EV
Mike Bossy
3​
17:07​
16:47​
0:20​
EV
Mike Bossy
3​
13:36​
12:32​
1:04​
PP/EV
Mike Bossy
3​
9:36​
9:02​
0:34​
EV

PlayerPeriodShiftsTOI
Mike Bossy
1​
6​
5:46​
Mike Bossy
2​
7​
7:33​
Mike Bossy
3​
4​
2:51​
Mike BossyTotal
17​
16:10

Overall, Bossy played 17 shifts, totalling about 16 minutes of time on ice. He didn't play a shift in the last 9 minutes of the game, when the Islanders already had 8 goals and a 5-6 goal lead. He was fourth in ice time among Islander forwards, behind Bryan Trottier (20:08), Bob Nystrom (17:36), and Bob Bourne (17:31).

And here are Bossy's three goals.

First goal by Bossy, a between-the-legs pass from Anders Kallur on the rush beat both Boston D-men, and Bossy beat Peeters with a quick shot.

Second goal by Bossy shows his absurdly quick release as he skated to the high slot and one-timed a saucer pass from the corner.

Third goal by Bossy. Potvin hit him with a pass for a breakaway on the power play. Bossy tucked it under Peeters while being hooked from behind and turned around. The announcers were just trashing Peeters for his poor lateral movement by this time,

Pavel Bure

I tracked Bure's ice time for a Toronto-Florida regular season game on March 17, 2001. Bure scored all three goals in a 5-3 loss to Toronto.




Here are Bure's three goals. First, second, third. On all three goals, he received a pass with speed in the neutral zone, skated over the blue line, and beat Curtis Joseph with a shot taken at speed.

Here are Bure's shifts.

Player
Period
Start of shift
End of shift
Shift length
State
Pavel Bure
1​
20:00​
19:10​
0:50​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
18:00​
16:30​
1:30​
PP
Pavel Bure
1​
14:45​
14:38​
0:07​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
12:20​
9:55​
2:25​
EV/PP
Pavel Bure
1​
7:00​
5:20​
1:40​
SH/EV
Pavel Bure
1​
4:25​
3:45​
0:40​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
2:40​
1:58​
0:42​
EV
Pavel Bure
1​
0:48​
0:00​
0:48​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
20:00​
19:00​
1:00​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
17:50​
16:40​
1:10​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
15:30​
14:03​
1:27​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
13:17​
11:33​
1:44​
PP
Pavel Bure
2​
10:10​
8:05​
2:05​
EV/PP
Pavel Bure
2​
6:40​
5:23​
1:17​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
5:10​
4:40​
0:30​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
3:04​
2:05​
0:59​
EV
Pavel Bure
2​
1:05​
0:00​
1:05​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
20:00​
18:55​
1:05​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
18:24​
15:34​
2:50​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
14:52​
14:20​
0:32​
SH
Pavel Bure
3​
13:05​
11:23​
1:42​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
10:10​
8:45​
1:25​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
8:00​
6:55​
1:05​
EV
Pavel Bure
3​
5:41​
2:50​
2:51​
PP/EV
Pavel Bure
3​
1:25​
0:07​
1:18​
EV


Player
Period
Shifts
TOI
Pavel Bure
1​
8​
8:42​
Pavel Bure
2​
9​
11:17​
Pavel Bure
3​
8​
12:48​
Pavel Bure
Total​
25​
32:47​

Overall, Bure played 25 shifts, totalling about 32 minutes of ice time, which was first on the Panthers. He played his most minutes in the third period, almost 13 of 20 minutes.

So we all know Bossy had some advantages. Better teammates and playmakers to set him up. He played in a higher scoring era against worse goalies. But he also had to play within a team system that was focused on winning. Many other great goal scorers would be out there in the last 10 minutes of the game trying to score more. And in the case of Bossy and Bure specifically, Bure played much more ice time.

I have no doubt to not believe you but Bure's game when you click on it has him playing 16:15 minutes that game which obviously must be a mistake right?
 

wetcoast

Registered User
Nov 20, 2018
24,825
11,665
Lemieux > Bure > Bossy > Gretzky

I think most hockey people who watched their careers would agree with that, although some might have Bossy 2nd.
Sure...maybe but it's hard to say as different people prefer different things and at least Bossy and Bure are known as goal scores first less so for Mario and Wayne really.

What I mean is that if someone asks you point blank what is the first word that comes to mind for each player and goal scorer comes up more often for Bure and Bossy than for Mario and wayne right?

As for the poll question, it's flip a coin for me as these 2 guys were both excellent goal scorers just completely in different ways and on vastly different NHL teams as well.
 

wetcoast

Registered User
Nov 20, 2018
24,825
11,665
Yeah. I mean there's an error somewhere but there is no need to go watch a whole game again :laugh:

We all know Bure played A LOT when in Florida.
Sure and no offense to the guy that posted those shifts, it's a legitimate area of inquiry but Florida at any time bure was on it and the NYI during Bossy's time are complete opposites in team construction to say the least.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hobnobs

overpass

Registered User
Jun 7, 2007
5,555
3,907
Ottawa, ON
I have no doubt to not believe you but Bure's game when you click on it has him playing 16:15 minutes that game which obviously must be a mistake right?

I posted a thread in By the Numbers on this topic. The NHL recently cut all single game TOI values for above a certain number in half. So Bure has a bunch of games in the second half of the 2000-01 season that used to have his TOI listed as 30-35, and now it's listed as 15-17. I think the 30+ numbers were correct.

 

wetcoast

Registered User
Nov 20, 2018
24,825
11,665
I posted a thread in By the Numbers on this topic. The NHL recently cut all single game TOI values for above a certain number in half. So Bure has a bunch of games in the second half of the 2000-01 season that used to have his TOI listed as 30-35, and now it's listed as 15-17. I think the 30+ numbers were correct.

Either way there is little doubt that Bure played more overall TOI/game but like I mentioned upthread part of that is obviously due to team construction as that Florida team was pretty awful.
 

Ad

Ad

Ad