Movies: Marvel Cinematic Universe Discussion - Part 4

AlanHUK

5-14-6-1
Nov 27, 2010
2,564
535
Nottingham, England
wonder if they'll push for a spider-man theatre release there now as well, could push it to #3 in all time worldwide gross for a short time before the new avatar takes that spot
 

beowulf

Not a nice guy.
Jan 29, 2005
59,648
9,178
Ottawa
Hmm I had heard rumors they were going to quietly bring Quake back with her playing the role. Wonder if that is what she means.
 

beowulf

Not a nice guy.
Jan 29, 2005
59,648
9,178
Ottawa

barriers

Registered User
Feb 10, 2020
2,798
5,068
I'm not going to click a link to his site to find out but I'm assuming he left out the part where she called him a loser
 

the squared circle

Registered User
Aug 3, 2005
1,618
1,296
Maple Leaf Gardens
Alpha Flight is one of the most diverse teams in the Marvel Universe.

I think it is a no brainer they get some attention soon.

YES PLEASE! I was so proud of Alpha Flight when they came on the scene around 82 or so, haha. I ended up buying the first 40 or 50 issues at a convention about 20 years ago. Why in Gods name did they kill Guardian off so soon?!? He was amazing and probably in my top five characters of all time.
 

Fripp

Registered User
Sep 6, 2005
2,304
545
Portland, OR
This douche actually acted like this was a scoop for him. Never heard of him but from some of the tweets he gets sound like he in an incel-far right type?

That was really weird. Writing an article about himself.
 

Superman33

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
2,653
1,464
Bucks County.
For anyone interested, you can click here to access a template Google Drawing I started a while back for ranking the MCU. The preview shows the ranking table, but the "grey space" on the sides contain the 31 released MCU cannon movies on the right and on the left is the 8 MCU TV shows from Disney+ so far. Once you click on "Use Template" you'll be able to click on and slide the titles into the rankings table.

Started this back in 2016 when I was teaching. Two of my colleagues and I had all three of ours on one file to compare our rankings. I also made a Google Sheet with the formula needed to determine the average rankings of each movie and conditionally format it so you could easily see the different "tiers". Essentially each of us had the same 5 movies in blocks with a few outliers here and there. If people share their rankings 1-39 I'll revive the Sheet and produce the updated overall rankings.

I hadn't updated mine since Falcon and the Winter Soldier, so I had some work to do. I try to base my ratings off of rewatchability, what it was like to see the movie the first time as an experience, and "Holy Crap" moments. I might have No Way Home and Multiverse of Madness higher than I think the overall movie is just because of the cool moments those movies provided in introducing us to the Multiverse.
View attachment 654880

Posted this over in the Quantumania thread and it was suggested people who frequent this thread might be interested, especially if you're staying out of that thread due to potential spoilers which I will spoil for you, there are definitely free flowing spoilers in there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pranzo Oltranzista

Pranzo Oltranzista

Registered User
Oct 18, 2017
3,977
2,894
Posted this over in the Quantumania thread and it was suggested people who frequent this thread might be interested, especially if you're staying out of that thread due to potential spoilers which I will spoil for you, there are definitely free flowing spoilers in there.
This is pretty cool - thx. I've played with it a little, but I really just can't... Some of these films are just a blur, and even those I've been rewatching at night lately I can often barely differentiate. It goes from 1. Black Panther to 38. She-Hulk (haven't seen the last Ant-Man yet), but in between, it's quickly impossible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Superman33

Superman33

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
2,653
1,464
Bucks County.
This is pretty cool - thx. I've played with it a little, but I really just can't... Some of these films are just a blur, and even those I've been rewatching at night lately I can often barely differentiate. It goes from 1. Black Panther to 38. She-Hulk (haven't seen the last Ant-Man yet), but in between, it's quickly impossible.

It is definitely a task to rank them all.

I used the Fantasy Football tiering strategy, hence the red lines on my list. I start moving the tiles into groups of "Like" and "Didn't Like" and then work on the top end and bottom end first. The middle is where things start to get harder to place, but from my list I figure anything 1-19 I'd be fine rewatching if it is on and 20-39 I'd probably choose something else.
 

KallioWeHardlyKnewYe

Hey! We won!
May 30, 2003
15,767
3,807
It is definitely a task to rank them all.

I used the Fantasy Football tiering strategy, hence the red lines on my list. I start moving the tiles into groups of "Like" and "Didn't Like" and then work on the top end and bottom end first. The middle is where things start to get harder to place, but from my list I figure anything 1-19 I'd be fine rewatching if it is on and 20-39 I'd probably choose something else.
I like the tier approach too because there's not a real meaningful difference between the 9th and 14th or 23rd and 27th for example in my mind. And my preferences may shift on any given day so 11 today could be 15 three months from now or whatever. But tiers are pretty solid for me.

I think I have roughly four groupings for the movies. Could probably break down a little further, but this is a pretty solid framework for me. Truly coincidental that it split mostly symmetrically. Wasn't intentional.

There's about 8 that I think are pretty good to great and I'd be happy to rewatch anytime.

There's another 8 that I like and would circle back to eventually. (Fine, but more positive).

There's 7 that are flawed in notable ways but still have some moments. (Fine, but more negative).

Then there's a bottom 8 that are completely forgettable or outright bad.

I haven't fully factored in the TV shows but my guess is that Loki would be in group one, WandaVision in group two and the rest spread out in some way in the bottom half.
 

Pranzo Oltranzista

Registered User
Oct 18, 2017
3,977
2,894
It is definitely a task to rank them all.

I used the Fantasy Football tiering strategy, hence the red lines on my list. I start moving the tiles into groups of "Like" and "Didn't Like" and then work on the top end and bottom end first. The middle is where things start to get harder to place, but from my list I figure anything 1-19 I'd be fine rewatching if it is on and 20-39 I'd probably choose something else.

I like the tier approach too because there's not a real meaningful difference between the 9th and 14th or 23rd and 27th for example in my mind. And my preferences may shift on any given day so 11 today could be 15 three months from now or whatever. But tiers are pretty solid for me.

I think I have roughly four groupings for the movies. Could probably break down a little further, but this is a pretty solid framework for me. Truly coincidental that it split mostly symmetrically. Wasn't intentional.

There's about 8 that I think are pretty good to great and I'd be happy to rewatch anytime.

There's another 8 that I like and would circle back to eventually. (Fine, but more positive).

There's 7 that are flawed in notable ways but still have some moments. (Fine, but more negative).

Then there's a bottom 8 that are completely forgettable or outright bad.

I haven't fully factored in the TV shows but my guess is that Loki would be in group one, WandaVision in group two and the rest spread out in some way in the bottom half.
I am now rewatching Captain 2 and 3 (can't watch the first one, which is lower tier to me, but I realize that my lower tier is a lot larger than yours... I'd count 15 movies and shows that I'd rank lower than The Incredible Hulk, which was barely ok - and I know, last on many lists, something I don't understand).

I'll report when I'm comfortable. :)

For sure, the Netflix shows (DD, JJ and Punisher) would rank real high on this for me.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad