The production gap I showed is actual results. It happened. That's how they performed. You're just trying to dismiss more accurate information, despite you doing the exact same thing with other opportunity discrepancies. If we're just going by raw points and nothing else, then I guess Marner is worth more than everybody who didn't have 224 points when they signed, right? Opportunity is irrelevant! McDavid was just a 40-50 point player in his first year, right? And he only had 46 goals when he signed! What a bum! And if goals are the end-all, be-all, I guess Matthews should have gotten more than everybody, eh? Ignoring critical information can be fun after all!
No, that's not what anybody said. You're mixing multiple different discussions together, to completely miss the point.
The production gap I showed is actual results. It happened. That's how they performed. You're just trying to dismiss more accurate information, despite you doing the exact same thing with other opportunity discrepancies. If we're just going by raw points and nothing else, then I guess Marner is worth more than everybody who didn't have 224 points when they signed, right? Opportunity is irrelevant! McDavid was just a 40-50 point player in his first year, right? And he only had 46 goals when he signed! What a bum! And if goals are the end-all, be-all, I guess Matthews should have gotten more than everybody, eh? Ignoring critical information can be fun after all!
No, that's not what anybody said. You're mixing multiple different discussions together, to completely miss the point.
You are saying that two players of the same draft/handedness and position who signed in the same year who have almost identical production in their elcs
Player A. Games 241. Goals 67. Pts 224
Pro rated 82 games. 23 goals and 75 pts
Player V. Games. 230. Goals.80 pts 209
Pro rated 82 games goals 29. Pts 74
There is an 18% per year and 10.2 million dollar gap in contracts.
You are basing this on “history”.
Show the history.
Show 2 players who scored similarly who had such a massive discrepancy in their contracts and what that was based on
Marner scored “28% more impacts” etc I every situation but somehow scored 13 less goals in 15 more games.
It’s just silly. We actually agree overall with most things. But there is no basis for this one.
If there is based on your “research” you would show it.