LW Quentin Musty - Sudbury Wolves, OHL (2023, 26th, SJS)

[TomBlizzy12]

What’s with these self entitled Americans asking for trades?

I didn't hear anything like this when Othmann & Barlow wanted out of Flint/OS

Canadian Bias is alive and well

 

[saska sault]

Sudbury's roster isn't as good this year...he just wants to go to a better team for his last year in the OHL. As a Canadian, who has lived in Sudbury before...this has nothing to do with being a self-entitled American...Canadian players do this as well.

Sorry to hear that you had to live in Sudbury.

 

[Mattb124]

Sudbury's roster isn't as good this year...he just wants to go to a better team for his last year in the OHL. As a Canadian, who has lived in Sudbury before...this has nothing to do with being a self-entitled American...Canadian players do this as well.

Sounds like it also plays into the criticism he got in Sharks camp for being all offense and not playing well away from the puck. Sudbury doesn’t sound like a good environment for Musty to improve on his deficiencies.

 

[William H Bonney]

What’s with these self entitled Americans asking for trades? Jesus

Thankfully for the CHL they don't have any non-Americans requesting trades.

 

[CanadienShark]

That is helpful to understand, thanks. Obviously Gushchin being 22, turning 23 in February, can help explain how he's ready to go, while Musty just turned 19.



Dickinson is like a ready made NHLer but I think there's an upside gap there with Musty.

I disagree on upside gap between the two. I think their upside is comparable (albeit different position), with Dickinson being more likely to be an impact player.

 

[JetsFan815]

We are now half a dozen games into the OHL season and this guy is still holding out. Unbelievable. The entitlement of refusing to report to an OHL team where you are gonna be there for 3 months to 8 months max is a bit much. Unless the Sudbury management was pulling some Mike Babcock shit on him (which I doubt as he's their top player) this doesn't seem good.

 

[SpezzaNoLookDropPass]

Unless the Sudbury management was pulling some Mike Babcock shit on him (which I doubt as he's their top player) this doesn't seem good.

Got the exact opposite actually

 

[CaptainShark]

Most Sharks fans agree that Sudbury is not a great place for him to further develop. He clearly wasn’t NHL ready and AHL isn’t an option.

I assume the Sharks are in on this and either told him to hold out or at least support him holding out.

Will be interesting to see how that works out.

 

[CaptainShark]

I assume the Sharks are in on this and either told him to hold out or at least support him holding out.

Grier in a recent presser basically said, the Sharks are NOT involved at all.

#WhatDoIKnow

 

[Kingpin794]

Got to be honest, I was wrong that this would still be dragging on by now. Not a good look for Sudbury. Going to hurt the return they get and agents for future players will take note. But hey, guess they showed him? /s

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

Got to be honest, I was wrong that this would still be dragging on by now. Not a good look for Sudbury. Going to hurt the return they get and agents for future players will take note. But hey, guess they showed him? /s

It depends. If they are getting good offers and trying to hit a home run it's on them. If they aren't getting any decent offers there is nothing they can do.

 

[bigdog16]

Sudbury holds absolutely zero leverage here and are making themselves look awfully dumb

1. He’s clearly not reporting, every day/game that goes by decreases his trade value
2. More players will be unwilling to report to Sudbury as a result of this

 

[oldwpgjet]

Good for Sudbury. He is a talented player and the offers will come. Let him sit until the trade deadline if that is his choice , only hurts him. They will get a boatload at the deadline if not before if they are patient enough and it appears they will be. Right and wrong ways to go about a trade , this isn't the right way. Teams are still figuring out what they have at this point , probably by December things will start to clear. I would just come back and play some hockey for awhile if I was him.

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

So, he just doesn't want to be in Sudbury ? I assume he wants to go to a better location, like London, or something, or just wants out of Sudbury ?

 

[Juxtaposer]

Good for Sudbury. He is a talented player and the offers will come. Let him sit until the trade deadline if that is his choice , only hurts him. They will get a boatload at the deadline if not before if they are patient enough and it appears they will be. Right and wrong ways to go about a trade , this isn't the right way. Teams are still figuring out what they have at this point , probably by December things will start to clear. I would just come back and play some hockey for awhile if I was him.

If Sudbury lets Musty sit out for three months, they've tanked his value. If an offer was coming that they were willing to accept already was on the table, they'd have taken it. Offers are only going to be worse as this goes on. This feels spiteful.

Lose-lose-lose for Musty, Sudbury, and the Sharks.

 

[Kingpin794]

Good for Sudbury. He is a talented player and the offers will come. Let him sit until the trade deadline if that is his choice , only hurts him. They will get a boatload at the deadline if not before if they are patient enough and it appears they will be. Right and wrong ways to go about a trade , this isn't the right way. Teams are still figuring out what they have at this point , probably by December things will start to clear. I would just come back and play some hockey for awhile if I was him.

There's an unspoken rule in the CHL that as a GM you don't play chicken with players that ask for trades. You move them and move on. No one's ever won by being willfully difficult about the request.

 

[William H Bonney]

Probably regrets not taking his NTDP offer in hindsight. You maintain more control over your development by going the USHL to NCAA route.

 

[coooldude]

Probably regrets not taking his NTDP offer in hindsight. You maintain more control over your development by going the USHL to NCAA route.

This was implied by will Smith in an interview a few months ago. I think someone linked to it a few pages back.

 

[frontsfan67]

Good for Sudbury. He is a talented player and the offers will come. Let him sit until the trade deadline if that is his choice , only hurts him. They will get a boatload at the deadline if not before if they are patient enough and it appears they will be. Right and wrong ways to go about a trade , this isn't the right way. Teams are still figuring out what they have at this point , probably by December things will start to clear. I would just come back and play some hockey for awhile if I was him.

They’d get more in return for a full season or 4/5ths of a season rather than half the year. Also hurts their brand when a big name player like this wants out and they aren’t trading him. Other players will take notice not to mention it’s way up north where people probably already don’t want to go and they’re one of a few OHL teams without a championship I believe

 

[Kingpin794]

They’d get more in return for a full season or 4/5ths of a season rather than half the year. Also hurts their brand when a big name player like this wants out and they aren’t trading him. Other players will take notice not to mention it’s way up north where people probably already don’t want to go and they’re one of a few OHL teams without a championship I believe


If the NCAA was an option this year I absolutely would think 100000% he would be going there. Sudbury is lucky this isn’t next season with the new rules implemented

He couldn't anyway as he's signed.

 

[frontsfan67]

He couldn't anyway as he's signed.

Oops. That’s right

 

[bigdog16]

Good for Sudbury. He is a talented player and the offers will come. Let him sit until the trade deadline if that is his choice , only hurts him. They will get a boatload at the deadline if not before if they are patient enough and it appears they will be. Right and wrong ways to go about a trade , this isn't the right way. Teams are still figuring out what they have at this point , probably by December things will start to clear. I would just come back and play some hockey for awhile if I was him.

It only hurts Sudbury. They get more for him in a trade now than they would at the deadline. You think he’s just sitting at his house eating chips? Hes on the ice daily