There were definitely "better" leaders than Brown through the cup years. Williams, Richards, Mitchell, and Greene are the first that come to mind. But stripping Brown of the C and keeping him on the team was just so wild.
With that said, there's been a lot of talk about hating on Brown, and I think it's a little unfair. I think pretty much everyone here loves Brown and recognizes all the amazing things he's done for this organization, and are also able to recognize and appreciate when he makes stellar plays (like he did last night), while also thinking that he should be getting a lot less playing time than he's currently getting.
Brown's the 10th-oldest player in the league. Hard to believe but it's true. Zdeno Chara, Joe Thornton, Andy Greene, Jason Spezza, Duncan Keith, Mark Giordano, Joe Pavelski, Zach Parise, Nate Thompson, Dustin Brown. Excluding defensemen, only Pavelski is getting more time on ice per game (and only 15 seconds more at that). Slight difference there though — Pavelski has 9 goals and 21 points in 26 games, while Brown has goals and 11 points in 28 games.
Brown is such a polarizing player this year. I think there's some middle ground to be found among us fans. I think his apologists just want some recognition for all of his accomplishments and everything he's given to the organization, and his critics want to reduce his workload and give some other players a chance. And
@Ray Martyniuk wants him to see the guillotine, but hey, we can't always get what we want.