Yes, I’m high on Mailloux as he is an intriguing player who possesses size, great shot, offensive vision and excellent straight forward speed. He easily has the best first pass that I have seen in a young player since Subban. But, in my opinion, this kid is not ready for the NHL and will probably struggle the first couple of months in Laval. He's only had one year of play in the OHL and his lack of playing time due to suspension was reflected in his lack of both conditioning and in-game awareness. Mailloux also has to get stronger on the ice so he contain forwards in the defensive zone. If Mailloux takes the next step in his development, he will be a force on our blueline for the next decade.
While I was watching Mailloux, I had the opportunity to watch the young Dickinson play on many occasions. This kid has all the tools to be an elite NHL defenceman. He has size, great mobility, shoots the puck as well as Mailloux and plays with a physical edge that Mailloux doesn’t have. The only thing he lacks what Mailloux possesses, is offensive vision. But Mailloux is two years older than Dickinson.
I would suspect that Montreal’s scouts had a chance to assess Dickinson while they were monitoring Mailloux’s progress. If they failed to see what this writer has seen about Dickinson, we need new scouts. I don’t care who we drafted in 2023, if we get a chance to draft this kid next year, and we don't, it would be an error. Some sites predict Dickinson will go 20th and later in the first round. There is no way that he goes past 10th. I suspect Dickinson will go much higher.