He wasn't on the road to busting.
He was in a slump and not producing and the sudden turnaround is proof of that. He was being misused but the elite skill was obviously still there, players with ability, confidence and work ethic like Cole do not bust, they just have to learn to deal with adversity that they have never encountered before. There is no such thing as ruining top talents. If a player is so fragile that they can not come back from adversity then they were never going to make it. That is the number one reason for the interview process. Strength of character/resolve/resiliency are every bit traits that are different for each player and are part of their overall skillset as much as skating, shooting and IQ are. These traits have a huge impact on how teams rank prospects prior to the draft because they greatly affect the prospects likelihood of succeeding.
I've got no idea if interviews of 17 year olds are remotely effective. My own assessment from a different field is that interviews might be overrated, where a large weight is given to a short sample of time heavily influenced by nervousness, biases, and random fluctuations. A friend who works in yet another field feels the same. I wonder if interviews are just a social construct to make managers feel useful.
I do think that Cole could have been ruined. Imagine if he had continued on his one goal pace, hen had his injury, then it came time for his second contract, then he started on the 4th like again?
You call Cole a can't miss prospect, but everybody (I mean everybody) thought that about Galchenyuk. And then about Kotkaniemi.
The HR management under the Bergevin administration was just atrociously bad. My all time "favorites":
- McNiven needing to pay out of pocket in order to practice, because the organization wouldn't get him access to ice.
- McCarron being told to not score goals.
- Leblanc playing on the third line behind Stortini and Hagel.
- Desharnais playing ahead of Galchenyuk, Eller, Plekanec, etc.
- Jacob De La Rose playing on the 4th lime in the AHL.
- Nate Thompson ahead of Kotkaniemi.