The first game back aside, it has to be repeated that teams that play physical against the Leafs always gives them trouble. 36-11 in hits and another 1 goal game. I won't be convinced that being constsntly hit won't wear a team down in a series. Far worse when the physical team is getting the PP opportunities
Maybe they will get lucky and draw the Devils in the playoffs. I don't want to overstate the importance but some physical presence couldn't hurt.
I also understand Keefes frustrations. The league can't have it both ways.
We've easily dispatched a bunch of physical teams this year. We are outhit in pretty much every game, and yet we have the 3rd best record in the league.
Even today, the refs and Samsonov made this a lot closer than anything the Blues did physically.
Also fun fact, in the playoffs since Matthews/Marner showed up, we have laid out 3 more hits per game in games we lose vs. games we win. In the 6 series elimination losses we've had, we have outhit the other team in all except one of them.
There is also no real correlation between the number of hits laid out and the teams that win the Cup. Tampa's first win and WSH were the only two teams in the top 5 in hits. Both of PIT's wins were near the bottom. Most of the time, the winners are somewhere near the middle of the pack in terms of hits laid out. The Leafs, for their part, are often in that 6-8 range in hits/60. Only our series against MTL, when we were all over them for most of the series and didn't have many opportunities to hit them, were we at the very bottom or anywhere close to it.
So I wouldn't obsess or worry about hits or physicality with this team. It is not the reason we are losing in the playoffs. We have done well keeping teams out of our slot and winning board battles under Keefe, both in the regular season and in the playoffs. We have also shown more intensity and consistent effort, which needs to come from everyone. Our goaltending needs to be better and we need to convert more of our scoring chances... and it is no coincidence that goaltending (and reffing to an extent, which has also been a problem in the playoffs for us) is the main reason why this game was even close.
Just to conclude with a shoutout to Sandin who has the most hits on our team while also dominating possession, which is a rare combination and hopefully calms some of the concerns about his shorter stature.