You really think that was what destroyed the Leafs' goaltending? Waiving a 37 year old to allow a 25 year old who just won a championship a crack at the backup position?
What hurt the leafs was
1) Not having an actual plan for Andersen after 2020 playoffs. He is 1 year from UFA, you just got Campbell at 1.6M who the upcoming 56 game season is expected to push 20-25 starts with potential to become #1 goalie
We should have dealt Andersen for 2 2nds or thereabout value after 2020. His value tanked in 2021 and he was a 5M negative asset who sat on the bench for 7 games vs MTL
2. Mrazek was a shitty gamble to make. He never was consistent and his #s behind a stronger canes defense were just average despite him being consistently injured. His play sucked and he was a non factor/option in 2022 playoffs vs Tampa. That was money poorly spent. We had to downgrade our 1st to a 2nd to move him
3. Murray trade was again piss poor. Too much caphit for a broken down player with term and declining play. Murray was injured most of 2023, and when he played was below average. We got lucky he missed 100% of reg season and were able to LTIR him this whole year. That trade could have cost us big time
Dubas was fine allocating 5M, 3.5M, and 4.6M i think for 2021, 2022, and 2023 on 3 goalies who were not good fits for our team, had declining play, and major injury concerns
That capspace could have been used to target a long-term goalie each of those years. Andersen if he went for 2 2nds gives us 5M cap space + 2 2nd rounders to get a long-term start in 2021.
Best UFA Guy was Ulmark to target
Trade wise: Gibson could have fit in long term with some retention for 2 2nds (retained to 5M), Kuemper was available, think MAF was available for a trade as well