Marner out would be a big shift in the team personality. Aside from that, I don't love Rielly in the number one role on defense, and I don't know if the answer is to put someone in front of him on the depth chart or to ship him out. I think Tavares is having a good comeback year so far and can gently manage the second half of his contract. Would keep Nylander. Would keep Matthews. If Samsonov continues on his path he could be our goalie of the future.
Matthews
Tavares
Nylander
Samsonov
If a major shakeup was to happen I'd like to see it be Rielly and JT.
The D needs an overhaul. Maybe something can be built around Lilly and Sandin but for too long this team has been missing their horse back there like a pietrangelo, parayko, Makar. We haven't had a game changing d-man since Bryan McCabe. Rielly's return would be solid. He's a great player, but he never took that step to game breaker, franchise level, player.
JT is having a hell of a start to his season. It's a resurgence. Saying that, it may be the right time to get out from that 11 million so it can be spent on depth and the blue line. Sell high, when possible...
Center depth is important, so if not JT, then Marner for sure. A wingers impact on each game has a ceiling. What he brings to the game is no more than what David Pastrnak, Kucherov, Connor, can bring. All 3 of those guys are paid less than Marner. For arguments sake, lets say Marner does bring more than those 3. Is it worth the lack of depth on this roster? He's not worth it in my opinion.
Matthews hopefully sticks around but I am a little nervous he has eyes on California.