Menzinger
Kessel4LadyByng
This critique is hard to get. We have asset that have been developing in one of the best euro leagues there is and seems to be one of the marque forwards there at the moment. If not the best outside of the KHL. He was nearly good enough as 23yo and now comes back as better player. If he adds compete here great, if we don't have spot and can trade him for minor asset great. If we waive him, nothing is lost.
It's not Malgins fault that he was traded for Marchment, who wasn't as 25yo the player he is now. So we basicly say that we shouldn't have given even Marchment a chance, because he was over the hill already, so why for the f***s sake we whine about that trade anyway.
If this pushes Robertson back the AHL for few months it's probably good thing for both players, if after this Robertson makes the team he earned it.
Unfortunately I do think the legacy of the trade has led to a bit of unfair criticism towards the guy. If he had a different name at worst you'd see maybe disinterest in the guy from some due to his size.
At the end of the day he's not blocking anyone, and his contract isn't stopping the team from signing another guy. He either makes the team and contributes (reward) or he's cut and fully buried (no risk)