LesCanadiens
Hardcore Curmudgeon
View attachment 763521
Dear Diary,
It is day 637 and the Lane Hutson debate is still not settled. Is he 5'8 or 5'10? No one knows for sure. Many of battles have been fought over this minor detail.
We will continue to draw broad strokes of comparisons and can only hope the arguments will finally settle - but that conclusion looks quite bleak at this point.
Will he boom? Will he bust? Everyone seems to know, but also not know at the same time. These are confusing days we live in. We will march on until he reaches the land of Montreal, and then we will critique every single play will utmost attention, and if he shall mess up, even once, then the bust-boys must have been right all along. The Boards will be flooded with "see, i told you he would bust!" and the vicious cycle will continue all over again.
Is he 5'8 or 5'10?
We may never know.
-fin-
I watched tons of him last season and mostly @montreal highlight/shift packages this season...here's my conservative take:
He's definitely NOT 5'8". I'd say the 5'10" stat is closer, if not a bit under. It's easy to see this with just the eye-test, unless of course he's wearing lifts in his boots.
Based on my personal observations, I don't see size and stature as the big detriment others do. I think his biggest detriment is his defending while skating backwards.
He is an incredibly smart player. AND appears to be a very competitive kid. So I wouldn't ever count him out of anything in any way. And that for me goes a long way.
He's obviously extremely skilled. His deceptiveness is elite-level and I think his IQ and on-ice vision is close to, if not elite. His edge-work is also elite-level. As is his stickhandling. You can literally see shit-stains form on defenders hockey pants in real time when trying to defend him. Especially in tight.
Having said all that. I truly think he'd struggle as a full-time NHL defenseman. So, I see a brighter future for him as a converted left-winger that plays the point on PP1. I truly think he can be a true NHL star in that role.