shadow1
Registered User
- Nov 29, 2008
- 16,728
- 5,526
A Brighter Summer Day (1991) - 10/10
In 1960 Taipei, a junior high school student becomes involved with a youth street gang after befriending the girlfriend of its leader.
I don't think anything I write in the next few paragraphs will be able to do this movie justice. Based on its acclaim, I am sure there are hundreds of essays out there somewhere; meanwhile I've just seen A Brighter Summer Day for the first time. But here are my thoughts.
This is a very lived in movie. Everything about it feels authentic, and you feel like you're watching real people rather than characters. There is some explanation for that. The film is based upon a real event, and director Edward Yang reported used upwards of 100 untrained actors/locals, including in key roles. Chi-tsan Wang (Cat) and Lisa Yang (Ming) were both sensational, but basically have no other acting credits.
To me, the themes of this movie are belonging and uncertainty. 1960 was only 11 years removed from the end of the Chinese Civil War, in which the Republic of China retreated to Taiwan following the Communist Party's victory. This movie paints a portrait of what life was like at that time: displaced Chinese, living under authoritarian rule, in previously built Japanese housing, with an American rock and roll music backdrop.
The movie focuses on the effects of these factors through one family. As the parents struggle to make ends meet, their children go down dark paths; for main character Si'r - their 14-year-old son, and fourth child - this involves becoming entangled with the local youth gangs. Over the movie's run time, we are witness to the corrosion this causes in his life.
Speaking of the movie's run time - it's 4 hours (3 hours, 57 minutes). It doesn't feel like it though. Even though it's a gut punch of a film, it's hard to look away thanks to its brilliant direction, cinematography, and acting. I scanned IMDB's reviews and I saw a few reviewers rate the movie a 5, citing its run time as excessive. I adamantly disagree; this movie needs to be long to give us the full impact of the events, as well as examining a lot of the more subtle moments that help steer the characters down the paths they end up on.
And this movie has a lot of characters. Though the movie focuses on Si'r and his family, A Brighter Summer Day also has story arcs for upwards of a dozen characters. Frequently, those arcs managed to subvert my expectations. One small example I can give without spoiling anything is the character of Honey; a gang leader the characters hype up to be a big bad, only for the film to show us he is a thoughtful, reasonable person.
Long story short, it's pretty much a masterpiece in my opinion. The next film, not so much.
Sleepaway Camp III: Teenage Wasteland (1989) - 3/10
One year after the events of the previous film, Angela Baker returns to the same campground after stealing the identity of one of the campers.
Ah, the old A Brighter Summer Day/Sleepaway Camp III double header. Probably the most popular double header in the history of cinema... said no one ever.
Sleepaway Camp III was filmed back-to-back with Sleepaway Camp II, and the same filming location is reused. Even so, this movie still manages to dial up the cheapness to another level - nearly the entire run time takes place outdoors, in the woods. The premise is that Camp New Horizons, opened on the same campground as last movie's Camp Rolling Hills, has re-opened with the concept of mixing together affluent and underprivileged youths. To do so, the campers and counselors split into three groups and go camping in the woods.
This obviously gives Angela - having killed and stolen the identity of a girl from the underprivileged group - a chance to go on a killing spree undetected, but it's an extremely lame one. She kills several people by hitting them in the head with branches, and one of them was even off-screen; we see her swing, hear the sound effect, and cut to the camper laying there with ketchup on their forehead.
Like in Sleepaway Camp II, the protagonist (Angela) is the killer, with the film not giving us many other characters to root for. Pamela Springsteen does a good job again, but there's no way she can save this movie. There's less humor here and Angela's character is a bit more insane. Last movie was fun because she comes off as a wholesome (but crazy) person who punishes wrongdoers with the death penalty. Here, she mostly just immediately kills everyone she meets.
Bad movie, and effectively the end of the Sleepaway Camp series. A fourth movie - with no Springsteen - was filmed in 1992, but got shelved until a home media release in 2012. A direct sequel to the original movie was released direct-to-video in 2008, but has horrible reviews. For now, I think I'll spare myself.
In 1960 Taipei, a junior high school student becomes involved with a youth street gang after befriending the girlfriend of its leader.
I don't think anything I write in the next few paragraphs will be able to do this movie justice. Based on its acclaim, I am sure there are hundreds of essays out there somewhere; meanwhile I've just seen A Brighter Summer Day for the first time. But here are my thoughts.
This is a very lived in movie. Everything about it feels authentic, and you feel like you're watching real people rather than characters. There is some explanation for that. The film is based upon a real event, and director Edward Yang reported used upwards of 100 untrained actors/locals, including in key roles. Chi-tsan Wang (Cat) and Lisa Yang (Ming) were both sensational, but basically have no other acting credits.
To me, the themes of this movie are belonging and uncertainty. 1960 was only 11 years removed from the end of the Chinese Civil War, in which the Republic of China retreated to Taiwan following the Communist Party's victory. This movie paints a portrait of what life was like at that time: displaced Chinese, living under authoritarian rule, in previously built Japanese housing, with an American rock and roll music backdrop.
The movie focuses on the effects of these factors through one family. As the parents struggle to make ends meet, their children go down dark paths; for main character Si'r - their 14-year-old son, and fourth child - this involves becoming entangled with the local youth gangs. Over the movie's run time, we are witness to the corrosion this causes in his life.
Speaking of the movie's run time - it's 4 hours (3 hours, 57 minutes). It doesn't feel like it though. Even though it's a gut punch of a film, it's hard to look away thanks to its brilliant direction, cinematography, and acting. I scanned IMDB's reviews and I saw a few reviewers rate the movie a 5, citing its run time as excessive. I adamantly disagree; this movie needs to be long to give us the full impact of the events, as well as examining a lot of the more subtle moments that help steer the characters down the paths they end up on.
And this movie has a lot of characters. Though the movie focuses on Si'r and his family, A Brighter Summer Day also has story arcs for upwards of a dozen characters. Frequently, those arcs managed to subvert my expectations. One small example I can give without spoiling anything is the character of Honey; a gang leader the characters hype up to be a big bad, only for the film to show us he is a thoughtful, reasonable person.
Long story short, it's pretty much a masterpiece in my opinion. The next film, not so much.
Sleepaway Camp III: Teenage Wasteland (1989) - 3/10
One year after the events of the previous film, Angela Baker returns to the same campground after stealing the identity of one of the campers.
Ah, the old A Brighter Summer Day/Sleepaway Camp III double header. Probably the most popular double header in the history of cinema... said no one ever.
Sleepaway Camp III was filmed back-to-back with Sleepaway Camp II, and the same filming location is reused. Even so, this movie still manages to dial up the cheapness to another level - nearly the entire run time takes place outdoors, in the woods. The premise is that Camp New Horizons, opened on the same campground as last movie's Camp Rolling Hills, has re-opened with the concept of mixing together affluent and underprivileged youths. To do so, the campers and counselors split into three groups and go camping in the woods.
This obviously gives Angela - having killed and stolen the identity of a girl from the underprivileged group - a chance to go on a killing spree undetected, but it's an extremely lame one. She kills several people by hitting them in the head with branches, and one of them was even off-screen; we see her swing, hear the sound effect, and cut to the camper laying there with ketchup on their forehead.
Like in Sleepaway Camp II, the protagonist (Angela) is the killer, with the film not giving us many other characters to root for. Pamela Springsteen does a good job again, but there's no way she can save this movie. There's less humor here and Angela's character is a bit more insane. Last movie was fun because she comes off as a wholesome (but crazy) person who punishes wrongdoers with the death penalty. Here, she mostly just immediately kills everyone she meets.
Bad movie, and effectively the end of the Sleepaway Camp series. A fourth movie - with no Springsteen - was filmed in 1992, but got shelved until a home media release in 2012. A direct sequel to the original movie was released direct-to-video in 2008, but has horrible reviews. For now, I think I'll spare myself.