Prey (2022) - 6/10
In 1719, the Comanche Native American tribe are stalked by cloaked extraterrestrial, The Predator.
I'm probably the last person in this thread to watch Prey. I went back and looked at the rest of the groups reviews, and I'm definitely lower on it than most; more in line with
@Pranzo Oltranzista.
The film has stunning cinematography, especially in the slower paced first half of the movie. The Predator creature only makes brief appearances during this time, and you almost forget you're watching a science fiction movie.
The second half of the movie went downhill a bit for me. I preferred the slower, more tension based beginning of the movie rather than the all out action of the end. For example, I thought the the trapper characters were a generic addition and they weren't on screen long at all; their only purpose was to up the body count and introduce the muzzleloading handgun that appears in Predator 2.
I wasn't a big fan of the main character, Naru. We're supposed to sympathize with her; she's in a hunter-gatherer tribe, and wants to be a hunter. In her pursuit of this goal, everyone around her tells her she's not cut out for it; the feedback ranges from constructive criticism from her brother, to flat out bullying from some other men in the tribe.
The issue is that there's a lot of truth in what they're saying. Naru is no doubt a talented fighter and she is a smart person in general, but she is not the cream of the crop on the battlefield. She should've been killed
several times; probably by the mountain lion, for sure by the bear, a few times by the Predator, and even once by nature itself (a bog).
Fortunately for her, she has some of the strongest plot armor I've ever seen, and always manages to survive by a stroke of luck. Unfortunately for everyone else, Naru is basically a narcissist who does whatever she wants, and her strong headedness puts members of her tribe in situations that lead to their deaths.
The ending was just okay for me.
Though Naru comes up with a clever trick to kill the Predator, she should've been killed - again - but was saved by her dog in the nick of time. I also thought by Predator standards, this creature was pretty dumb. It was difficult for Arnold to outsmart the big bad in the first movie, which added tension; the Predator here falls for Naru's trap pretty easily. As a result, the movie ends with Naru being named the new War Chief of her tribe. No lessons were learned by her; she received the gratification she desired but it didn't feel earned, as she pretty much lucked her way into surviving the movie.
Not a bad movie, but I was hoping it was going to be the clear #2 in the series, and I can't say that. Maybe my opinion will change over time, but for now I'm lower than IMDB's 7.2 rating.