BigKing
Blake Out of Hell III: Back in to Hell
If playoffs were the main expectation, why wouldn't TMac and Blake be forcefully saying so before the season? Throwing the gauntlet down, lightning a fire under the team's asses, whatever you want to call it. I agree with you that those moves were meant to meaningfully improve this team, but I disagree that it was a make-or-break playoff year. Arvidsson was a reclamation project. Edler had been declining. Danault for sure was a big play, but we had no idea Moore and Arvidsson would blow up playing with him.
I think your point about getting contributions from different places than expected is a great one, but I think the fact that we're doing this well when some of the younger guys haven't emerged yet is even more encouraging for the future. I look at players like Kyrou and Terry elsewhere on top of the awesome development of our young defensemen. We had more spots on defense, and players stepped up. I've been frustrated more spots haven't been open in the top 9, but the forwards have demolished the AHL this year and guys like Kaliyev who did make it to the NHL have continually improved.
I'll stop this rant here, but I guess I'm just trying to paint an optimistic view of your points. I get not subscribing to it, but I'll throw it out there anyways.
I don't disagree with @Herby very often but I have thought from the outset that this season was not "playoffs or bust" but rather the following:
- Be in the thick of the playoff race
- Have the top-flight prospects, sans Clarke, push for spots and/or become key contributors allowing Blake to know what he has on his hands
Danault is a long-term signing even if this might be the best season he ever puts up. He is supposed to eventually be an elite 3C or 2B center to one of the young guys. Arvi was cheap and a case of Blake having dry powder and taking advantage of a situation. If he kept sucking, no big deal.
The problem is that the top-flight prospects--except for Kaliyev--have been very disappointing so Blake either still doesn't know what he has at the forward position or he knows it isn't what he hoped it would be. The counter to this is that Sean Durzi is playing 25 minutes a night right now, Spence has jumped in and looked legit and Bjornfot was really coming along. Forward was supposed to be the strength of this prospect pool but it definitely looks like a shift has taken place and Blake is going to have to adjust on the fly.
Make no mistake: they want to make the playoffs but the lack of activity here at the deadline should confirm what I've thought since the start of the season--they did not go "all-in" with the Danault and Arvi moves. Whether they make or miss the playoffs, the biggest weaknesses will look to be addressed in the off-season and Blake is going to have to finally move on from some of his children.
What they couldn't have this season was a repeat of last year. Even with a complete collapse here down the stretch, said potential collapse will be pinned on injuries.