Schenn, Simmonds, Johnson, and two 1sts before ever winning a playoff series.
Considering that they were out of the playoffs at the time of the Carter deal, that entire seeies of events could've been a disaster.
For someone who loves getting hyper specific with semantics, I'm not going to allow you to wander off into absurdist hypothetical land.
Your described series of events was NOT a disaster. That's the reality you're conveniently ignoring. The Kings won two Stanley Cups in three years. Trading Schenn, Simmonds, Johnson, and two 1sts for in-their-prime Mike Richards and Jeff Carter was not "throwing the future away." It was supplementing an already established core, a future that was alive and present on the Kings at the time. And guess what? It worked.
You continue to entrench yourself behind these unfalsifiable, ambiguous hypotheticals because you have no real position. In your mind, Lombardi deserves criticism for trading away young players because it *could* have gone bad. And of course, Blake deserves more charity because his moves or non-moves *could* work out in the long run. Coulda, woulda, shoulda.
None of this actually addresses reality. So here's reality again, no matter how much you try to run from it:
Reality: Dean Lombardi established an identity and a vision for a rebuilding team. Under this vision, he quickly identified, established, and nurtured a young core. When the core struggled in their ascent, he fired the coach, and made two major trades to continue supplementing the core with more established, prime players. The team went on to win two Stanley Cups.
Reality: Rob Blake has not established an identity or vision. He has waffled between trying to contend and trying to rebuild multiple times. When faced with clear roster issues, he has up to this point failed to act and address those issues. The team has won nothing.
This is the reality. I'm not interested in what could've happened in 2012 under Lombardi, or what may happen in 2023 under Blake. I'm interested in what DID happen, and what IS happening.