What has Shanny done or said that makes you think he has any intention of trading the core four?
I get that the CJ report may be unwanted news. But there's nothing so far than tangibly disproves it.
How do we know Shanny himself didn't directly leak it to CJ for that matter?
You can't disprove a negative .. So there would be NO evidence of something he didn't say or didn't happen. Only Shanahan and the core 4 players would be in the loop and know exactly what was said on a private conversation. They would be the only people that could prove or disprove that statement. Not hearing them directly claim its true is not evidence it happened either.
I'm not suggesting one of the core 4 would/should be traded, I'm questioning the validity of a statement made by someone in the media with no evidence that wasn't there nor directly involved.
Suggesting that Shanny himself leaked it to prove CJ statement as true, would simply be more unproven speculation on top of other speculation that again couldn't be disproven if it never happened. Do you have any evidence to support your Shanahan leaked theory, or did you just make up that possibility yourself as plausable, without any real proof it actually happened, and now asking me for assistance to help prove it.
The only person in fact that
I personally heard that has ever hinted at the potential of 1 of the core 4 being moved was Dubas himself at his own PC.. When asked directly by CJ himself nonetheless, Kyle said "All options are on the table". Thousands of Leaf fans that turned into the press conference can confirm that.
Here is that proof that my last statement is true.
Maple Leafs' Auston Matthews, Kyle Dubas express desire to remain in Toronto
If Dubas remains as the general manager, all options are on the table, including trading a member of the Core Four which includes Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner, John Tavares and William Nylander. Dubas cited the Matthew Tkachuk-Jonathan Huberdeau blockbuster trade from last summer as a precedent.
“I would consider anything with our group here that would allow us a better chance to win the Stanley Cup. So I would take nothing off the table at all. And I think everything would have to be considered with regards to anything to do with the Leafs.”
Everything you need to know from the Maple Leafs end-of-season media availabilities.
ca.sports.yahoo.com
Perhaps it was the Kyle Dubas news that was unwanted, and his removal that has secured the core 4 future? If you wanted the core 4 to remain then Dubas removal should come as good news.
It wasn't the Dubas firing that sent the core 4 players speculating about their Leafs long term futures, it was what Kyle actually did say during his press conference that lite that fuse. When Shanahan heard Dubas go public with that news, he fired Kyle. and then in an attempt to put out the fire. he called the players himself directly to reassure them the organization is not actively looking to trade them. Or at least that is what CJ is claiming Shanny told them in private. What Shanny actually said I can't prove as factual, you would have to trust Chris Johnston on that one.