Nobody really knows exactly what the market and the alternatives were. Regardless of anybody's position, it's all based on assumptions. Lots of good discussion on this even on this page.
Exactly and at some point you have to pull the trigger somewhere. Dorion made it pretty clear that there were net minders they liked (at least one) that could have potentially been explored via trade, but that Ottawa was on NTC lists.
Korpi was their top UFA choice based in the recommendations of both goalie coaches, the AGM, the pro scouts, Forsberg who has a history with him, and his own personal viewings in the playoffs last season.
He may not have been their first choice all things being equal on the trade front, but it does look like it was a well consulted move across the organization. That sounds promising at least.
In the end we only have the facts surrounding the move we did make, and very little on the moves we didn’t. We’ll never know if there was someone better we could have had unfortunately. We do no that Ottawa is not a desirable destination in general sadly, so even getting a guy like Korpi as a UFA is kind of a win in my books.
I like that his success last year seems like it could be his new lease on life after fixing his hips. Lots of potential for this to be the healthy guy going forward. We’ll have to wait and see.