Player Discussion Kirby Dach: Welcome to Montreal part 2

[417]

Freak accident....good one. Playing hockey is FILLED with freak accidents. Do people think players get injured on purpose? Heineman is a freak accident....Dach was injured playing a tough sport.


So trading Boqvist has nothing to do with the rest.

Tinordi’s knee happen to catch Dach’s knee just at the right time (or wrong one) which is what caused the injury.

That same play could happen 100 times and 99 times out of those 100, Tinordi’s knee doesn't strike Dach’s at that angle.

It was a freak injury…you’re digging deep here WS.

 

[Redux91]

https://www.journaldemontreal.com/2023/10/17/un-historique-inquietant-pour-kirby-dach

Since 2019:
Concussion
Wrist injury
Right shoulder
Lower-body injury (never precised)
Concussion
Knee injury

Let's hope he gets away from freak accidents....

Man, so what do you WANT exactly?
Invent a time machine to go back and reverse the trade? Ok Good luck
OR trade him this summer? Not bloody likely
Like ,
What do you want man.. Tell us.

 

[McGees]

Man, so do you WANT exactly?
Invent a time machine to go back and reverse the trade? Ok Good luck
OR trade him this summer? Not bloody likely
Like ,
What do you want man.. Tell us.

 

[Toene]

Tinordi’s knee happen to catch Dach’s knee just at the right time (or wrong one) which is what caused the injury.

That same play could happen 100 times and 99 times out of those 100, Tinordi’s knee doesn't strike Dach’s at that angle.

It was a freak injury…you’re digging deep here WS.

Should've trained his ligaments, such a slacker.

 

[Whitesnake]

Man, so what do you WANT exactly?
Invent a time machine to go back and reverse the trade? Ok Good luck
OR trade him this summer? Not bloody likely
Like ,
What do you want man.. Tell us.

The ONLY thing I said before the outrage machine started kicking was that it was possible that the Hawks knew something we didn't. That's the ONLY thing.

What I want? The possiblity on a hockey forum to say that. Too much to ask?

[mod]

 

[Redux91]

The ONLY thing I said before the outrage machine started kicking was that it was possible that the Hawks knew something we didn't.

WS, how can you not see how ridiculous that is tho..
How can anyone predict freak ACL tears.. if you had the answer
The NFL would make you a rich rich RICH man..
You're insinuating a sports team monitored the Knee ligaments of their players somehow and deemed, somehow amazingly, that Dachs tendons on their magic Xrays showed that his were deemed ripe for a tear in the not so distant future.. and so they must trade him .. like..what??

 

[sampollock]

No sentence captures my feelings more accurately right now.

Yes. Not Kirby's fault at all

 

[Andy]

The ONLY thing I said before the outrage machine started kicking was that it was possible that the Hawks knew something we didn't. That's the ONLY thing.

What I want? The possiblity on a hockey forum to say that. Too much to ask?


Yeah, and other complain about posters. Somehow, I guess it makes you better.

Or they traded Dach because they thought, like many of the self appointed Galaxy brains on this board, that he wasn’t going to break out.

No one spoke about his knee. Everyone was concerned about his wrist and whether he was a bust. When both those narratives were gone to blame management with, y’all are jumping to a new invention to feel better about yourselves.

 

[Andrei79]

It's pretty lame that people are using this freak injury to argue that Hughes lost the Romanov trade.

The injury saps my enthusiasm for the Habs, and the inane hot takes sap my enthusiasm for the forum.

Precisely this.

 

[Habs Halifax]

The ONLY thing I said before the outrage machine started kicking was that it was possible that the Hawks knew something we didn't. That's the ONLY thing.

Do you actually think the Hawks knew something we didn't though? Like for real? Everyone knew about the wrist injury. Are you trying to tell us a wrist injury is prone to injuring your knee?

Can you explain this a bit more? Is something being taken out of context or do you actually think a Wrist injury means a knee injury is to follow? This makes no sense if that's your angle and you would deserve the backlash that comes from it.

Clarify your stance in what you think the Hawks knew about a future knee injury?

 

[417]

Dach woke up Saturday morning and said to himself, “how can I put myself in a position to not only tear my ACL, but that pesky hard to tear MCL too”.

Lawd

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

 

[Andrei79]

I think it's pretty clear what the Blackhawks knew.

It's that they would send Tinordi to injure Dach and thus win the trade. The league should investigate.

Am I doing this right ?

 

[Lafleurs Guy]

Well, on the plus side I’d say we’re probably going to finsh on pace for a top five pick now.

 

[McGees]

C'mon guys.
90% HAWKS WANTED BEDARD.
10% they also were uncertain about Dach fullfilling potential of a 3rd overall.

 

[sampollock]

Stop blaming Dach and the Hawks knew.
Sad

 

[JoelWarlord]

The darkest day in Canadiens' history

 

[Lafleurs Guy]

WS, we actually like you around here..cmon man
We just want to help because you're going slightly a little overboard here..
We're all upset with the news, but your posts make it look like you've WRECKED your living room lol..

WS is a great poster. But I think he’s way wrong here. It was a fluke injury. Sometimes you just get bad luck.

 

[The Great Weal]

Man the Hawks fans saying that this might be karma for Dach's celly in the shootout winner last year are a unique level of stupid

 

[admiralcadillac]

Shit...and here I thought you were all supposed to agree with me....better luck next time for me. I will find something. Here.....David Fischer was a bad pick. Please agree.

You keep impressing me with the clarity of your hindsight

 

[Whitesnake]

Or they traded Dach because they thought, like many of the self appointed Galaxy brains on this board, that he wasn’t going to break out.

No one spoke about his knee. Everyone was concerned about his wrist and whether he was a bust. When both those narratives were gone to blame management with, y’all are jumping to a new invention to feel better about yourselves.

You know what...yeah, they could. It's YOUR TAKE. And it could be THE right one. I reserve myself the right to have an opinion that COULD potentially be the wrong one.

Feeling better about myself? About what? Dissing the trade when it happened? Loving to see the Habs lose 'cause I hated Bergevin? And here I thought you were the common sense guy.

Though, here's a comment I made July 2022. THE DAY OF THE TRADE!

GDT: - 2022 Upper Deck NHL Draft: Bell Centre, Montreal, QC | ROUND ONE July 7th @ 7 pm ET | ESPN, ESPN+, SN, TVAS: PART 2

Okay well that move rocked my f***ing socks boys that makes the Slafkovsky pick a lot more acceptable in my eyes.

forums.hfboards.com

Here's another one...

Confirmed with Link: - Alexander Romanov & Pick #98 Traded to NY Islanders for Pick #13 & Flip It + Pick #66 to Chicago for Kirby Dach

I love Romanov but i doubt he's more than a #4. Trading him for a young middle 6 center with size who is already good defensively is a good bet. You won't get an actual top 6 center for Romy.

forums.hfboards.com

Here goes your NOBODY thought about being afraid of injuries......

 

[Habs4Life]

View attachment 753888

exactllllllllllly

 

[Kennerback]

Some guys are made of glass. They don’t play different than others. Shit just keeps breaking down for some unexplained reason. Benoit Brunet, Carlo Colaiacovo, etc… Year after year after year until they‘re forced out of hockey. You tell yourself they can’t just get injured again and they do. I hope it’s not the case here.

 

[417]

I think it's pretty clear what the Blackhawks knew.

It's that they would send Tinordi to injure Dach and thus win the trade. The league should investigate.

Am I doing this right ?

Tinordi was the player the Habs traded to get John Scott, right?

If the Habs end up finishing last as a result of Dach’s injury…

I think it's safe to say that we finally won that trade.

How bout’ Dem apples!

 

[River Meadow]

Well, on the plus side I’d say we’re probably going to finsh on pace for a top five pick now.

The tank's back on boys.