I think your stance on the Tkachuk contract matters in this instance because you are picking stats that are favourable to Norris to justify the same or greater money for Norris.
Why not pick the most important piece of the team in Chabot and use his $8M to compare? Why not use Bathersons deal as a comparison? Drake outscores Norris, so why should Norris make more than him?
Brady is the Captain of the team and the face of the franchise, Losing him would have been to basically invalidate everything they've said they are doing. He''s also one of the few power forwards left in the game. His value goes beyond points and you don't want to get that....but it's a thing. The team absolutely paid a premium to keep him and that wouldn't apply to all players. Josh Norris agent is not going to argue for Bradys contract because everyone knows why Brady got that deal and that he represents the ceiling in terms of the teams spend on players.
For Norris, I think Suzuki would be the top end ($7.8) but players like Petterson could also be used as a top young scorer. It would depend on the term but $6.5 to $7.5M would be my number for Norris.
I'm not cherry picking stats though. I brought up Brady's points and Norris goals. If those stats paint one side as better maybe that has something to do with their actual performance?
Chabot is 25 and plays a different position while Brady and Josh are similar age and even play on the same line and same situations. To compare their performance and contract is natural.
Doesn't losing Norris also invalidate what they are building? Because he is our 1st line center right now, our best two way forward, and arguably our best power play weapon. What are we doing if we lose Norris?
And yea Senators will use Batherson contract but Norris agent will probably just call Drake's agent a dumbass. We got lucky Drake signed his contract before Brady. Can you imagine Drake negotiating his contract right now?
So let me get this straight our cap structure is that our potential 4th/5th best player on the roster is the cap ceiling for the rest of our talent? Like everyone else is gonna outperform Brady on the ice but will be happy to make less because he's the captain and his last name is Tkachuk? I don't think it works like that either.