If that’s true, it’s hard to figure out why Vesey chose the Rangers, a team in decline, a team whose Stanley Cup window has closed, a team whose best player (goalie Henrik Lundqvist) is nearing the end of his productive career, and a team with salary cap issues. Vesey won’t likely compete for a Cup any time soon in New York, and by spurning the Bruins for that city’s chief regional rival in most things, he likely lost the love of his passionate and emotional hometown fan base.
Vesey admitted on a conference call that joining friend and Boston area product Kevin Hayes in New York was appealing, but the main reason he cited sounded a lot like one of those bland responses you get in a carefully crafted team press release.
“The thing that jumped out at me was that they came to really want me,†Vesey said. “It seemed that they really needed to have me in their lineup and it seemed that they believe in me. That was something that I was looking for.â€
Give me a break. Every other team pursuing Vesey “really†wanted him.
Chicago GM Stan Bowman was on hand to watch Vesey play repeatedly and the Blackhawks reportedly offered him a spot alongside Jonathan Toews. Buffalo traded a draft pick to acquire exclusive negotiating rights with Vesey’s camp. Nashville had him in three development camps.
We may never know why Vesey truly chose New York, but some NHL executives had ideas.
“He was promised big money after his entry-level deal,†said one executive, who requested anonymity while also expressing a buyer-beware sentiment on Vesey.
“He wants the big stage like Hayes,†said another. “Be careful what you ask for. That city will eat him alive.â€
Vesey said the Rangers don’t need him to be savior, but all the hype surrounding his signing has absolutely increased the pressure on the Harvard product. There is nowhere to hide from the spotlight in New York and let’s not forget that his good bud, Hayes, has been little more than a mediocre player in New York after spurning the Blackhawks, who drafted him in 2014.
With the Rangers, Vesey could begin his rookie season as the No. 3 left wing behind Rick Nash and Chris Kreider, or higher if the Rangers are interested and able to find someone to take the final two years of Nash’s eight-year, $62 million contract ($7.8 million AAV) off their hands.
While multiple NHL executives told Today’s Slapshot they believe Vesey has the tools to become a top-six wing (he had 56 goals and 104 points in 70 games over his last two seasons at Harvard), there is far from a consensus on the former third-round pick. Analytics guru Rob Vollman provided an interesting analysis on Vesey’s potential that you can read right here.
Maybe it will all pan out for Vesey in New York. This was, after all, his choice and nobody else’s to make. But if his decision had been “based purely on a hockey decision,†as Donatelli suggested, there were numerous options better than New York.
In Chicago, he would have been guaranteed almost instant success playing alongside Toews on a ready-made Cup contender. Ditto for Pittsburgh. In Buffalo, he would have joined an up-and-coming roster, and in Nashville, he would have joined what is arguable a better roster. Even Philadelphia offers a talented prospect pool that could pay dividends in the next couple years. Of the remaining suitors, only Boston’s future seems markedly worse than the Rangers’.
We won’t know for two years, but maybe that one NHL executive was right. Maybe this was just about getting paid down the line. In the end, that’s usually what drives these decisions regardless of the marketing lines falling from players’ and agents’ lips.
At least this overblown story has ended. As far as over-the-top hype goes, this case ranks near the top, given Vesey’s draft status and the ridiculous lengths many teams went to land him.