Exactly. It's a matter of talent not size to me. It would be great if we had a Headmon or heck another big guy like Trouba who could play extremely well but we don't.
We have big, generally poor positional dme like Stanley that just run around in their end against good players.
Stan's a 3rd pairing guy that's in and our of the line up - he's not our biggest problem yet he's the guy everyone's talking about.
If you have guys on the blue line making 5 to 6 times his money, I'd probably point at them - especially if they struggle as much if not more, than Stan (defensively).
As for size vs talent, I agree with you -
My beef is that our small guys that are supposed to be so talented, are not. They put up a few points with their assists and all is forgiven despite the fact that they do not know how to plan the position they are named (defensemen) - and we blame it on systems.
With skill being equal, the big guys on the blue line will have an advantage over smaller defenders - they can at least use their size to stop guys in their tracks, squeeze players out, funnel them off into the corners, or move them from one place to another.
They also instill a little fear out there with freewheeling forwards roaming around in your zone - basically at will.
Why do you think Florida paid a 1st+ for Chiapet - he ain't no Ville but he makes you think twice about setting up in front or chasing down pucks in the corners.
Meanwhile, the same skill in a 180 lb dman, is going to struggle with the rotation and middle ice traffic - because they get run over.
When apposing teams coaches flip off to the media about how easy it is to play the Jets in their zone, it's time make it a little more unpleasant.