I got my list in last night, though I feel very uncertain in several places. I mostly tried to make sure I had people in the right range and didn't worry too much about the minor rankings between individuals, since we'll (hopefully) work those details out in the coming weeks.
It struck me that all the big name early guys- Moran and LeSueur being the best two, but I've seen people throwing around Hern, Nicholson, Paton, Hutton, etc- all come from the East. Is it true that all the best goalies were in the East at this point, or are we looking at geographic bias? I'm leaning towards bias at the moment.
Here are a couple more quotes about some of the early western goalies that I've been really trying to get a handle on over the past ~10 days. I'll continue searching through the weekend since people will be submitting their initial lists and maybe it will influence some people.
The first quote comes from the Toronto Star, 4 March 1905 Page 8. The article is discussing the 1905 Rat Portage team that was being sent East to challenge for the Cup. Rat Portage would ultimately lose the challenge (2 games to 1, scores of 9-3 (RP), 4-2 (OTT), 5-4 (OTT)), though it was one of the best/closest series the Cup had seen to-date.
GIROUX IN GOOD FORM
GIROUX as a goalkeeper has performed more consistently than any other goaltend in the league with the exception of "Dutchy" Morrison of Portage la Prairie, though Charlie Quinn of the Rowing Club when in shape is the best there is in the Province. Quinn in late games has been off. Giroux was about three-quarters of the defence when with the Marlboros, and he figures largely in the Thistle games.
1905 Manitoba teams and (primary) goalies
Winnipeg Victorias: Mouat Little and Jack Warren
Winnipeg Rowing Club: Charlie Quinn
Rat Portage Thistles: Eddie Giroux
Brandon Wheat City: Claude Temple
Portage la Prairie: Dutchy Morrison
1905 was one of the peak seasons in how the talent was split between various leagues. In addition to the Manitoba league, the East was split into 2... actually 3 top tier leagues in the CAHL, FAHL, and IPHL. So we are looking at really 4 leagues and 21 teams that had a claim to be playing at the highest level.
CAHL teams and (primary) goalies:
Montreal HC: Oliver Waugh
Quebec HC: Paddy Moran
Montreal Westmount: Fred Brophy (the goal-scorer)
Montreal Shamrocks: Mike Kenny
Montreal Victorias: Nathan Frye
Montreal le National: Joseph Cattarinich
FAHL teams and (primary) goalies
Ottawa HC: Dave Finnie
Brockville HC: Kerr
Cornwall HC: Jack Hunter
Montreal Montagnards: Henri Menard
Montreal Wanderers: Bill Baker
IPHL teams and (primary)- Since I haven't been through this league yet I am less sure about if these were indeed the primary goalies, so someone please fact check me if I am wrong
Calumet Miners: Billy Nicholson
Portage Lake HC: Riley Hern
Michigan Soo: Joeseph "Chief" Jones
Pittsburgh Professionals: Jack Winchester
Canadian Soo: Pete Maltman
Maybe its just because I have spent a lot of time in this era over the past 2-ish years, but that is a lot of names that received significant praise, both during the careers and after they ended. Sometimes long after. And it is pretty well split; 3 of the four leagues has 2-3 names that really stand out to me
Manitoba: Morrison, Quinn, Giroux
CAHL: Moran, LeSueur are the big names, and Cattarinich spent some time in the NHA
FAHL: probably the weakest goalie talent here... Finnie, Menard, Baker, and Hunter all had decent careers, but none are what I would call particularly significant in a historical sense
IPHL: Nicholson, Hern, Winchester
I haven't really decided what this all means yet, haha, but I wanted to get some thoughts down. Are we (or just me?) overrating some of these guys? I count 8 names there that I spent some real time on, trying to figure out who/how many should be on my list.
Alright, that is enough of that. The second quote is from The Province (I believe British Columbia... Vancouver?), 20 November 1908 Page 13, though the story is in several papers across Canada.
The Ottawa club, by the way, is hurting to get together a team. Negotiations have practically been completed for the signing of Jack Winchester of Toronto to play goal. Winchester played last year with Winnipeg Maple Leafs and is considered quite up to the standard of Paddy Moran. Winchester was reported signed by Wanderers, but Ottawa got there first.
By November 1908, Ottawa HC had Percy LeSueur and the Wanderers had Riley Hern... and these teams were thinking about replacing those two (big) names with Jack Winchester? Does anybody know if LeSueur or Hern had other offers on the table, or was Winchester considered an upgrade?