Senscore
Let's keep it cold
- Nov 19, 2012
- 21,380
- 16,904
Management GM Pierre Dorion/Front Office Thread - Part IX [Mod Warning in post 1)
- Thread starter AchtzehnBaby
- Start date
- Status
AchtzehnBaby
Global Matador
I like Zub but paying him more than $4M - 4.5M AAV would be an over-pay.
We may have a Zub replacement in JBD in a year or two. I think Lassi Thomson could become a top 4 D too. I see both as potential 2nd pair D in the future. I hope they turn out to be that good.
We may have a Zub replacement in JBD in a year or two. I think Lassi Thomson could become a top 4 D too. I see both as potential 2nd pair D in the future. I hope they turn out to be that good.
bert
Registered User
Neither are as big or as hard to play against. You need physical d men. The sens don't have any. He's the only one. Look at Tampa look who Colorado went out and got.
Would not be an over pay he plays 22 minutes a game. An over pay would be 6 + million. He is a unique player. Solid top 4 d men are few and far between. There are literally none available.
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
This probably is the likely outcome, not the alternative.
Zub has shown flashes of being a $5 million dman but he’s also showed flashes worth something less.
He signed a really low contract to get to UFA as fast as possible. I think the writing is on the wall.
As a side note … Francis seems to think Zub would be open to an extension.
Pierre from Orleans
Registered User
- May 9, 2007
- 27,302
- 19,751
I don't think he's very physical. Very smart defensive defenceman yes.
What did he say
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
I agree - he’s isn’t a physically intimidating dman. He isn’t even physical.
There's no way Chychrun is going to sit out training camp with a contract. Libelous insinuation from Francis.
It’s speculation. To draw clicks. There are more sinister insinuations out there lol
ReginKarlssonLehner
Let's Win It All
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
Ugh - I’d have a lot of concern for Zub at $5 x5. I could see his play stagnating over time something like Z’s. It may not end up as bad but I don’t see him getting better and think it could get worse.
It also locks $5 million into our 3RD best D or possibly 4th beat D. If we acquire someone like JC. Your 4th D can’t make $5 million.
The average cost/player off $80 million payroll is around $3.5 million … someone needs to balance out the guys making $8-10…
Someone’s probably done the math here -
ReginKarlssonLehner
Let's Win It All
Yea, we aint re-signing Zub if we get JC.
We are only signing Zub if we get Larsson like contract of lower. Not JC.
The whole point of getting JC is to bring in Thomson/JBD as replacement for Zub and not feel the loss cause our top 3 will be a brilliant trio of Chabot, Sanderson and JC.
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
Agreed - I don’t see how we could acquire both. I’d hope Dorion could trade and recoup some assets for Zub in that case.
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
AchtzehnBaby
Global Matador
Good stuff. Let’s move the Zub talk to the Zub thread and save this thread for Dorion and management specifics… please
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
Good stuff. Let’s move the Zub talk to the Zub thread and save this thread for Dorion and management specifics… please
Agreed … What is this thread supposed to be ? Clarification would help.
Is it a place to debate what Dorion should do with his 3-4 F slot ? I’m sensing it’s not …
Or is it the place to make memes trolling Dorion’s public speaking skills …
AchtzehnBaby
Global Matador
None of the above.
This thread is for constructive discussion on the current management. Any deviation into toxic or trolling discussions will result in thread bans.
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
Sounds good to me - you should clear out the 2 year old stale rehashed Dorion insults on here …
what constructive service do they offer ?
bert
Registered User
He initiates tons of contact. Being physical isnt just big hits, he uses his body very well sperating the man from the puck, protecting pucks and pinning players. Zub is a much better fit for this team in terms of need, position and style of play than Chychrun.
If his play stagnates he’s still worth that money. He can play on our top pair and play well with our number 1 d man. Now if we get chychrun there’s a choice to be made as there is a cap of course like you said
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
Even if we get JC we don’t have a single big body dman on the roster. Hamonic was a necessary acquisition for this front office. the cost we paid will probably be made up in any future negations Dorion has for another D … simply because he is that much less desperate for a dman and he can’t wait out Phoenix or whoever.
Your view on acquiring Hamonic confuses me. As if simply acquiring any RD is a heroic feat on its own. Even if potentially not very good
Sweatred
Erase me
- Jan 28, 2019
- 13,408
- 3,326
Last spring I saw something that had Hamonic as the 10-12th best available solution. Do a UFA search for right D and you’ll see how thin the options are. Than factor in player discretion and term.
Getting Hamonic secured a decent option as a big body / right D. There is still room to add more but if we don’t we can start the season. Getting ahead of this was a nice move by Dorion and the FO.
Hamonic expires and we’re not committed to 3-5 years. Lots of better D options but they all didn’t want to come here.
- Status
